← All episodes

Dine Originals Week

Sep 15, 2017 · 53 min

Dine Originals Week is fast approaching! Hear from the organization’s executive director about the deals you can take advantage of while enjoying Columbus’s finest independent restaurants and learn about the pitfalls of public relations in Columbus.

As a bonus this week, I sat down with the founders of the new restaurant Ambrose and Eve, slated to open in German Village next year.

Shownotes

Read the transcript

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the Confluence Cast presented by Columbus Underground. We are a weekly Columbus-centric podcast focusing on the civics, lifestyle, entertainment, and people of our city. I'm your host, Tim Fulton. This week, on the occasion of Dine Originals Week coming up September 18th through 24th, I sat down with Shelley Mann, Dine Originals Columbus' executive director, to talk about the organization, some of the restaurants you can check out during Dine Originals Week, and we talk about Shelley's work doing public relations in Columbus. And in a bonus interview, I spoke with the founders of the restaurant Ambrose and Eve, slated to open in German Village next year. You can get more information on what we discussed today in the show notes for this episode at theconfluencecast.com. Also, the Confluence Cast is on Patreon. Find out how to support this podcast on our website, theconfluencecast.com, or at patreon.com/confluence. Enjoy the interviews. Sitting down here with Shelley Mann, the executive director of Dine Originals Columbus. Shelley, how are you? I'm great. How are you? I'm doing well. Coming up towards the end of September, September 18th through 24th, we are sitting down here on the occasion of Dine Originals Week. The 35 Dine Originals restaurants will be offering prix fixe three-course menus, uh, for a fixed price. That's what prix fixe means. To customers to basically come and check out their restaurant. Shelley, tell us what is Dine Originals? Yeah. Dine Originals is a nonprofit organization. It's been around for over a decade, and really, the, the goal is to provide a group of independent restaurants in Columbus to sort of band together-

Mm-hmm ... and really talk about, you know, what are the benefits of eating, uh, dining out at your independent restaurants. Okay. So we're really helping to market and promote our city's independent restaurant scene and trying to educate diners on why it's important to support these restaurants and keep the money in our community, as opposed to choosing a chain restaurant when you're going out to eat.

Gotcha. And so- Yeah ... by virtue of them banding together, they can focus their marketing efforts together. Yeah.

A big, big part of that is Dine Originals Week. Mm-hmm. You guys also every May do an event called Taste of Dine Originals at Franklin Park. So what, as a consumer, what do you offer me? Well, yeah, so we are-- One of our main ways that we bring in revenue is we sell gift certificates to the consumers-

Mm-hmm ... through our website. And so we collect gift certificates from all of our member restaurants, and then we sell those back to the customer at 30% off face value. Okay. So we do our sales four times a year, so it's a quarterly sale.

Oh, so you can't just go on at any time. Well, you can, but- Depending on if they're available. Yeah. So-

They sell out ... the popular ones sell out- Okay ... right away. And then-

Who sell-- I'm not gonna-- Let's not talk about who doesn't sell out, but who does sell out quickly? Oh, man. So, you know, The Refectory, theirs sell out really quickly. Okay. Skillet.

What's the price point? Like- Barcelona ... is it, like, 50 bucks, 100, or? We have different price points. So we have some that are $50 gift certificates, and you can buy them for $35.

Okay. And then we have $25 gift certificates that you can buy for $17.50. And then we have some that are $10 gift certificates that you can buy for $7.50. I see. So we have all different prices.

And that depends on the restaurant and the price point- Yes ... that the restaurant is. And they're not trying to-- They don't set a point where it's like, "Oh, it's only $10, and our average meal is $12." It doesn't really happen that way, right? No.

Okay. They can choose what denomination they wanna sell. I see. Yeah.

And when does that sale happen? Those happen every year. So our, our most recent one ha- launched the first week of August. Okay. And then-

Still some stuff on there. Yeah. Okay. There's still some stuff on there to check out. And then we'll have our next one in November, the first week of November. So it's, generally, it's the first week of February, May, August, November.

Gotcha. Yeah. And the, does the November one tend to be more popular because- It does

... people- Holiday shopping. Right. Well- ... and you don't-- The gift card doesn't say, "I bought this for 30% off." That's true.

There you go. Yes. Save 30% on your gifts this November. Talk about Dine Originals Week and sort of what some of the participating restaurants are. What's the price range of the menus? Yeah. So Dine Originals Week, actually, this is a fun fact for you. Dine Originals Week was Columbus' first Restaurant Week.

I remember when it was the only- ... Restaurant Week. So yeah, when Dine Originals was founded, it was really founded by the restaurants. They- Mm-hmm ... they banded together. And at that time, there was a national Dine Originals organization.

Oh, okay. So there would be Dine Originals groups in different cities across the country. Is that not a national organization? It's actually, it's not a national organization anymore. There are still chapters in some cities.

Do you consider yourself a chapter of it? Were you part of the larger organization? We were part of the larger- Okay ... organization. So the larger organization does not exist, so we're not technically a chapter. We did form into our own nonprofit organization after-

Gotcha ... the national organization disbanded. Okay. But, you know, at the time that Dine Originals was created, Restaurant Weeks were kind of a new concept.

Mm-hmm. And, you know, a really exciting way to get people going out to eat- Mm-hmm ... on slow time, during slow times of the year for the restaurants.

Right. So that's why we do them in, we do ours in March and September. Okay. And, you know, we're really trying to get people to come in on week, on weeknights as well.

Right. So, you know, the special runs through the weekend, but restaurants a lot of times are, you know, struggling to get people in on the weeknights of these times of year. Right. So our Restaurant Week, we took a little hiatus-

Okay ... and then we brought it back starting last year. And so we do these, like I said, twice a year. Mm-hmm. And all of our restaurants offer... Generally, they're three-course menus, and you get them for the fixed price point.

Okay. So you know, you know what you're gonna pay going in. Our menus range in price from $15 up to $40. Okay. And the restaurants can decide-

What's like a $40 restaurant? The Refectory, uh, theirs is actually $39.50. Oh. Okay. I don't know if anyone has exactly 40. Yeah, so they're, you know, like some of the higher-end restaurants are doing the $40.

Got it. And then someone like Chile Verde Cafe- Okay ... theirs is in the $15-

Gotcha ... price range. And so you're getting three courses, so you're getting like- Right

... an appetizer or salad or soup portion- Mm-hmm ... a main course, and then a dessert tends to be- Typically, yeah.

Yeah. And the menus are all different, so, you know, it's, it's, it can be really fun to kinda poke through. We put them all online on our website. So some of the restaurants, you'll do- And plug the website for me ... dineoriginalscolumbus.com.

And that will be linked in the show notes as well. Go on. So some of the restaurants will do something like, you know, a soup and salad, and then an appetizer, and then a main course, or, you know. So some of them don't include a dessert, or maybe you get, like, two kinda main coursey type things. Okay. So they're all different, and they're all really interesting-

Cool ... just to kinda look through. But, and generally, you know, for the Restaurant Week, the chef is doing something a little more creative. Okay. He or she are working in seasonal ingredients.

Mm-hmm. Um, so this time around it's, you know, there's a lot of wild game meat and- Okay ... you know, warmer soups and kinda l- turning towards the fall.

So while the items are typical of the restaurant, these are special items. Yes. Gotcha. So they're definitely things that you can only get during Restaurant Week, so it's another reason to go out and check these menus out.

Great. How does a restaurant join Dine Originals? What are the, the requirements? Yeah, the requirements are you have to be independently owned and operated. Okay. So that means, you know, you're the-

McDonald's cannot join ... owner that works in there. Yeah, no, any chain restaurant cannot join. Okay. If you're owned by, you know, a, a company that owns many other restaurants-

Or you're a franchisor. Yeah. Right. So you have to have six locations or less-

Okay ... as well. So we do have some local chains who still count. What's an example of that? Well, Chile Verde Cafe does have two locations-

Okay ... so that's an example. The Wine Bistro is- Okay ... I remember they have right now three locations.

I didn't realize they were- The Wine Bistro ... locally owned and operated. They are. And they actually just bought Catsingers.

Really? Which means that they have four locations. Is that news? No.

When did that happen? Hmm, last year. Okay. But someone like Cameron Mitchell, while there may only be two Cap City Diners- Right

... he owns a significant number of- Yeah ... restaurants. So he has The Pearl-

Right ... The Old House. He probably has six in Short North. Yeah. Well, he probably has six in one block in the Short North. Listen to my interview with Katie Randazzo later for- ... more digs and yet respect of Cameron Mitchell. Cool. And so what do they have to... How do they... Are they contributing a check? How do they- No. Yeah

... how do they join? So our dues are actually those gift certificates that I just mentioned. Oh, okay. So it's actually an easy way for a restaurant to, to join something like this because they're re- they're donating gift certificates to the restaurant.

Mm-hmm. We sell them on their behalf. So it's- So they're actually, uh, they're not even giving you anything. No.

They're allowing you to- To sell the certificate ... to sell, rather collect revenue. Right.

But then they honor the gift cards. They honor the gift card. Got it. So they don't get any money when you bring in the gift card in.

Gotcha. So- But typically, you know- ... make sure you're tipping ... yes. Please make sure you're tipping heavily.

Yes. And a lot of times, you know, especially if it's a $10 gift card, I mean, you're probably spending more money when you go in- Got it ... than just the $10.

Got it. So, you know, we're helping to bring new, new customers into the restaurants that might not go in otherwise. We're helping to fill seats that might be empty otherwise- Mm-hmm ... for the restaurants. So there are a lot of benefits for the restaurant to joining and in doing our gift certificate program.

And then, so how did you get here? What's your- I, I sort of know this story, but what's your background that brought you to Dine Originals? Yeah, so I started out in journalism- Mm-hmm ... and I was working for The Dispatch printing company.

Mm-hmm. And I- So this is the time in the episode where gonna give my full disclosure that you and I- ... used to work together tangentially- Yes, at Alive

... for The Alive. Right. Right. Yeah, so when I was at Alive, the, you know, higher-ups at The Dispatch started talking about wanting to start a food magazine. Mm-hmm. And I was on some of the early committees and talking about the food magazine, which became Crave.

Okay. And- Is Crave still around? No-

Okay ... sadly. So and then- My, how many ancillary products we've seen come and go. And I ended up being able to be the first editor of Crave when it launched.

Mm-hmm. So that was a magazine covering the restaurant scene in Columbus. Mm-hmm. And once The Dispatch was purchased by GateHouse... Gate- GateHouse, right? Yeah.

GateHouse Media, yeah. They did close down both Crave and Capital Style, unfortunately, but- Oh, that's when it happened. Yeah.

Oh, okay. But yeah, so I was writing stories about the restaurant scene for my, for my job back then, and I got to know a lot of the chefs and owners- Mm-hmm ... and things like that. And so I actually, for ve- a lot of different reasons, I decided to leave the journalism world-

Okay ... and start my own company, which is called Umami Consulting. Okay. And I was... I still do Umami as well, but so I-

You can hire her ... work with independent restaurants and help them with marketing and PR efforts. Okay. So what I was seeing when I was interviewing these chefs and owners is that a lot of the independent restaurants, you know, they don't have, they don't have the budget to hire someone specifically dedicated-

To do marketing ... to doing marketing. Right. And so they're doing it themselves and, you know, the owner is doing the marketing, or the chef is doing the marketing, and they don't really have the time or capacity to do that.

They wanna be running a business, right? Yeah. So being able to offer, you know, packages designed for restaurants- Mm-hmm ... to help them tell their story-

Okay ... was, seemed like a need in the city, and it c- It has been, you know What do those packages look like? Is it like, what's the low end? Not price point- ... but what do you actually offer on the low end? Yeah, I mean, so like a low end would be a-

One press release for- ... a PR. Yeah Okay ... like a PR package where, you know, a- anytime you're having a special event or something that you-

Mm-hmm ... wanna spread the word on, you would call me up and I would write a press release for you and send it to all the local media outlets- Mm-hmm ... and-

And you do some follow up and- ... get it on the calendars and- Yeah ... yeah, try to get you media coverage.

Got it. So that would be a low end. And then for some of my clients that I'm working with, I do everything from helping them with purchasing ads- Mm-hmm ... figuring out where are the best places to spend their ad money and, you know, h- how big their ad, you know, should be, and then designing the ads for them.

Got it. Coming up with ideas for marketing campaigns and promotions, and then- And even helping organize events then. Yeah.

Right. Organizing events, I do a lot of that. And then, you know, social media, that kind of thing- Gotcha ... I can also help with.

Makes sense. Yeah. Can we talk about the movie? Wait a second. We can.

Okay. But let me j- say how I got to Dine Originals- Okay. Finish that ... finish the story.

Sure. So I was doing Umami and then Dine Originals approached me when their previous executive director left- Okay ... Catherine Moore.

Okay. And asked if I could take on the executive director role, and it actually, it fits in really nicely with what I'm doing already. Yeah, absolutely. So it's really just about marketing and, and doing, you know, public relations work for the independent restaurant scene. And so a lot of my clients are actually were Dine Originals restaurants and are Dine Originals restaurants, so.

Gotcha. Yeah, so it was a really good fit. And so I do, this is just a part-time job for me, but- Got it. That's great. So, and part of your sort of freelance and contract marketing efforts, you actually worked, uh, with the, what's his name? Morgan Spurlock.

You actually worked with Morgan Spurlock's company when he came into town and did that little pop-up joke restaurant for the movie that... It hasn't come out yet, right? It's premiering this month at the Toronto Film Festival. Okay. So it's- I don't know when that starts

... it's doing the festival circuit. Yeah. Can you talk about that experience and what it was like? What's the name of the film? It's, I guess it's gonna be called, uh, Super Size Me 2.

Okay. Holy Chicken! Holy Chicken! And Holy Chicken! was the name of the pop-up restaurant up in Westerville. So the press surrounding it, to be clear, your role was literally public relations for this. Yeah.

That- Lo- local public relations. Yeah ... local public relations. So your job was to convey to the media that this thing was happening, that Morgan Spurlock was behind it, and you did that. You were paid to do that. And so you sent out press releases, you contacted television stations, you actually did some outreach to city officials, correct? Correct.

And so there was some backlash there because even though the name Morgan Spurlock was attached to it, everybody just got all, I think Columbus does this too much, got all sort of excited about a famous person being here and said, "Isn't this great? Everything must be on the up and up. This i- this isn't a joke. No one's making fun of us." And I... And so give us the rundown basically on what Holy Chicken!, what that pop-up restaurant was. Yeah. It's not a joke. I mean, I, I still stand by that statement. Okay. So, and I have not seen the movie, so I-

Okay ... I, I, you know, I'm looking forward to seeing it and, and seeing how everything- Mm-hmm ... turns out to be portrayed. But yeah, so what happened is the Morgan Spurlock's team-

Mm ... film team contacted me just through, uh, Googling, like- Columbus restaurant PR ... Columbus restaurant marketing.

Right. PR. And so I came on as a, as a, you know, a, a paid, like- You were a consultant ... consultant-

Right ... for this project. And yeah, exactly what you said. You know, I, we, we shared the information that there, it was going to be a pop-up restaurant- Mm-hmm ... brought to you by Morgan Spurlock, you know, documentary filmmaker.

Of, of Super Size Me fame. Right. And he's trying something different out, which we were very specific in describing the, um, the sourcing of the chicken. Mm-hmm. And used, you know, exactly the words that he wanted to use and-

Okay. Wait, so even the press release was like, what's the, the halo of health? Yeah, exactly. Okay. So, you know, I think, uh, like nothing was ever false, nothing was ever... Everything that we said was exactly what you got when you got to the restaurant.

Right. So, you know, it's like people hear the word- Fresh ... fresh, farm fresh.

Right. And they assume that it's something- That it's healthy. Right ... specific. And yeah, you assume that it's, that it's healthy, even though we actually, you know, like gave ahead of time the calorie information for the sandwich-

Right ... which was absolutely not healthy. Right. Like, it was more calories than a Big Mac.

Well, it's why people perceive that you go to Chipotle and you're eating a 2,000-calorie burrito and that- Right ... that, that, that is somehow good for you. Right.

It's not. You're engorging yourself on food. Exactly. And then, you know, the, the words that we use to talk about the, the farm that the chickens were raised on are exactly the words that anyone's legally allowed to use- Right ... to, to describe the situation that these chickens were raised in, which-

But they're not anything special. No, it's not. You know, I think y- what people- They're not ... have in mind if they hear farm fresh, farm raised chickens-

All chickens are raised on farms ... and free-range. Yeah. All chickens are raised on farms. Right. Is that they have access to, you know, an area that's just, it just needs to be a few feet by a few feet, that if they can make it out of, you know, this chicken coop that they're in-

Right ... then yeah, they can, they can graze. Call it free range. Well, and that's sort of- But it's not the pasture raised that you're imagining when you hear-

Right ... those words. Well, and that's the whole point of the film is- Yeah

... sort of pointing out- The whole point was that. Right And the whole point is actually much bigger than that. And so, you know, what this was, wa- was just talking about the rest- the restaurant part of it.

Right. And actually, the goal through the restaurant was to figure out if, if, like, is there a better way to do this? Is there a better model? And as far as I know, I'm not in direct contact with Morgan's team. Okay. I get asked-

Your contract is done ... on a, a regular basis. But yes, I was just hired to do the promotion for the Holy Chicken Take- uh, Pop-Up Restaurant- Mm-hmm ... that happened last year. But from what I hear, there actually still are plans to open a Holy Chicken franchise.

Okay . And you know- So- ... after the movie comes out. So there, there was nothing really-

So we're- ... joke or a hoax- What we're burying here- ... about this whole thing, but-

So you ... So once you went into the restaurant, again- Yeah ... the mayor showed up. You know, every television station showed up. You actually transferred, you came to my house and transferred- ... with a, a production assistant to get the footage from the news station, so I imagine that will be in the film. When you go, though, to the restaurant, there are sort of snarky sayings pointing out to you, "Hey, this is this many calories," and, "Hey, this water is actually just Columbus tap water, and it's probably the healthiest thing that you can have here." And so the news crews, everybody shows up, and I think they felt duped be- but that's actually the point. Right. I mean-

But the problem is, is they actually, they, they felt duped, but they still went ahead and did a normal, quote-unquote, this famous person is doing a pop-up, and didn't talk about what he was trying to prove because they couldn't... 'cause it's difficult to put that into a four-minute news story. Well, yeah, exactly. I mean, I think you probably need a two-hour movie to- Exactly ... really explain the whole thing.

Yeah, and I don't think we're even properly explaining it, but I think the, the, the point I wanna make is you actually got in hot water with your media contacts because they were like, "How could we possibly ever trust you again?" And it's like, I didn't lie to you. I literally just transferred information. I was hired because I know you, and Morgan, and you ate, literally ate it up. And I just th- I, I would hope that those relationships are on the mend at this point, and everybody's sort of like, "Oh, I get it. This isn't Shelley's, quote-unquote, fault." I just think it's an interesting ... We as a city need to be a little bit... We should certainly continue to be smart and open, but we need to be a little bit less starstruck- ... when things happen, so. Yeah. Yeah. The whole situation, I mean, it's, it's... I've never experienced anything quite like it. Yeah. You know, I hope that-

Do you regret it? ... people... I'd like to see the movie, movie before I- Make a decision about that ... will tell you if I regret it or not.

Are you in the movie, do you think? But I would say not. I, I don't know. Were you on camera much? Yeah. I mean, I was on... There were cameras in the restaurant the entire weekend, and I was there the entire weekend, so.

But you were never, like, interviewed and asked- No ... like, "How'd you... Did you dupe these people?" No.

Or any- No. Okay. No, no, no. No, and you know, I think that my hope right afterwards is that everyone, you know, would believe me when I say that I would never do anything to harm Columbus or, you know-

Right ... if, if they asked me to do, to take this on, like, "Hey, we have this project where we're going to trick the city of Columbus into eating something that they didn't agree to eat," I would've said no. No, I'm not interested. You know? Like, no way. So you know, the, the, the bigger mission behind the restaurant in terms of I think that when you go into a restaurant and you read a menu, you should understand what you're getting. And, you know, if you go into the grocery store and you see free-range eggs and you pay, like, $3 more than you would for the carton next to it, that you should be getting a better product.

Right. I mean, that's what really- And realizing that it's not necessar- It may be a slightly better product, but- Yeah

... you need to be an educated consumer and, and know what that value is. Right. And that value, I would hope, isn't just associated with marketing lang- Marketing, right

... marketing language. Exactly. Yeah. So you know, the whole, the bigger concept is something that I really stand behind.

Mm-hmm. And I hope that the movie can make a difference in that way. Yeah. And so in that way, no, I don't regret it. And I, you know, yeah, like I said, I mean, I, I was really hired to do a job, which I did, which is-

Yeah ... get people to come out to the pop-up restaurant. You know, I, I think what Morgan's goal... You know, he wanted people to come out and experience it and not kinda get the, you know, the- Not get what he was doing to them. Yeah, like not-

Yeah ... you know, like read an article that explains exactly what it was- Exactly ... and then feel like you don't have to go because you get it now.

You get the joke, right. So he wanted people to come out and experience it, and that's what we did. You know, we got a lot of people out there. Yeah. And a lot of people had a great time. A lot of people really liked eating the food. A lot of people, um-

'Cause it wasn't a bad chicken sandwich ... understood what was going on. Yeah. No, yeah. The chicken sandwich was great. It, it tasted just as good as, you know, like in-

Any other chicken sandwich ... crazy restaurant chicken sandwich would. Um- Right. So yeah, it was, it was definitely, it was definitely interesting. And yeah, I mean, I will always say, like, as soon as I s- When I send out a press release about a restaurant opening in Columbus-

Mm-hmm ... generally, it's kinda crickets. I mean, you know, like the most we can hope for is, you know, like an article- A blurb ... in The Dispatch-

Right ... and something on Columbus Underground- Right ... and you know, something like that, and a review in Alive.

Right. When I sent out a press release saying that Morgan Spurlock is opening a restaurant in Columbus, immediately it was every news outlet called me back. Yep. So I found that to be just interesting.

Yeah. We need to stop doing that. So- Cool. Shelley, uh, thank you so much for your time, and again, check out Dine Originals Week, September 18th through 24th. Yeah. Say thank you. Thank you for having me.

Sitting down here with Matthew Hagens and Katie Randazzo, the chefs and co-owners of Ambrose and Eve. Ambrose and Eve up to this point has been a pop-up experience around Columbus, uh, for sort of a dinner party atmosphere. They are opening up a new permanent space on High Street, just south of... Tremont. Yeah, it's right next to Tremont and, like, Clotches Republic. Okay. And we'll be next to the new Seven Sons Sour Beer Bar that's opening up as well.

Oh, fantastic. When's that coming? They think they're gonna be open in a couple months. Okay. That's ambitious. They're ambitious people.

We all are. Yeah, that's why we like them. We all are. Give me the elevator pitch on Ambrose and Eve. Ambrose and Eve is named after my dad's parents, and what we're trying to build is a-

We wanna have a nice, fun dinner party every night. Okay. And we want you, we want you to feel like you're coming to one of our grandparents or mother's house, and you have a really good time, but at the end of it, you have to help pay for it. And I assume that will translate in the atmosphere and also the food. It's not people have to show up at a set time. It is a traditional restaurant.

It's a... It's gonna be a very traditional restaurant. The menu will change very frequently based on what's available- Okay ... seasonally and the things that we're interested in. We'll be focusing mostly on Americana. Okay.

Trying to update that and make that a little bit more interesting, but we'll do a, a lot of other modern preparations as well. Give me some examples of dishes people might get there. My grandmother was notoriously famous for making veal parmesan, and I say veal in quotation marks- Okay

... because it was actually chicken. And she believed that if you pounded it thin enough, then no one would know the difference between the veal and the chicken. Okay. So it was a tradition every time we would go visit her in Akron, she was like, "Oh, try my veal parmesan." We're like, "Okay, Mimi." You know? So one of the first things we discussed when we were discussing the restaurant and the concept and the name and everything behind it was that story. Okay.

And so- And so did you get there just because you were looking for a name, or you set out and you were like, "I'm gonna do this and I'm gonna name it this"? It was... The name has been in development for, I would say, about two years almost. And there was a couple other spaces that we had looked at that fell through. Mm-hmm.

But I was f- I was very dead set on naming it Ambrose and Eve. Got it. I think it has a nice flow to it. It's masculine, it's feminine. Yeah. Ambrose is not a name that I'm actually familiar with.

Right. It's a really old school name. Yeah. What's sort of the short... You're Matthew and hence Matt. Is there a short version of Ambrose?

Bro. Well, and it should be said, your background, Katie, you are the proprietor of originally Hala Food Truck and also Hala, which is in- Woodlands ... Woodlands Tavern.

Yeah. How did you get into this business? Well, I used to date this girl. I met her six years ago, I think. Okay.

She lived in New York at the time, and I was feeling very stagnant in Columbus, and I liked her, so I decided to move to New York and push my boundaries and learn more about the culinary field and get more educated at that as well. And she's Jewish, and I was in the process of opening a food truck, but I put it on hold to move to New York. Okay. And she moved back with me to open the truck. Mm-hmm.

And because she had not ever worked in the service industry, we, we or I, had decided on doing Jewish food because I wanted a way for her to feel connected to the business- Okay ... and be able to fit in and bring some ideas to the table. But you're Jewish as well.

No, I'm not. I'm Sicilian. I didn't know that. Yeah, I'm not Jewish. My nose confuses people- ... but no, I'm J- I'm not Jewish. Well, I guess I always assumed because you were the proprietor of-

Right ... you know, a, a Jewish food establishment. Well, I opened a Jewish food establishment based on this ex-girlfriend. Okay.

It's important. It's important. Well, sometimes that's the way it goes. The ish part is really important there. Yeah, Jew-ish.

You know, it's Jewie, or, you know. Yeah. And so Hala's going well, and sort of this Ambrose and Eve is sort of the next endeavor for you. Correct, yeah.

Great. And Matthew, I don't believe you and I have ever met. I don't think so. Where... Tell me about your background. How did you get here? I don't know. 39 years ago, my parents met.

Two people loved each other very much. That's too, that's too far back. Well, that's questionable. I used to work in, like, I don't know, an office. I used to work for AT&T for a really long time.

Okay. I worked there for eight years, and I think I liked it for eight days. Okay. Eventually, they offered me, uh, an early retirement, and I took it, and I had been cooking off and on and then before that.

Okay. And it's something that I like doing. I like taking care of people. Uh-huh. So-

Dinner parties in your home, or you were- Well, I mean, I worked- ... cooking on the... like working in a kitchen on the side? Like working, yeah, working in a kitchen on, on the side. I got laid off from AT&T, and I worked at this little place called Elemental that was over where Black Creek Bistro is now.

Yeah. Yeah, like actual employment from time to time- Okay ... but mostly it was kind of like fun stuff. So I cashed out my retirement and went to DC and-

Okay ... got a job at a fine dining restaurant and got my... got the shit kicked out of me for, like, a full year. Okay. Um, and then kind of like half got it kicked out of me for a couple more years. And then I bought a food truck and drove it back-

Okay ... and ran a food truck here for a couple of years. What food truck is that? It was the Swoop food truck. It was-

Ah, okay ... really big in this neighborhood. Yeah. It was huge. We did some, some additional pop-ups, and were kind of like growing on track to get a restaurant open, and then some things happened.

Okay. And then I didn't do it anymore. So- Well, and that's the way that kind of stuff goes. I mean, as someone who was passively involved in a, you know, food establishment, that's sort of how things happen. Yeah. It's life. That's what happens.

Mm-hmm. So then I was at the Flatiron for a while. Okay. Then I was at the Rossi until pretty recently.

Okay. And now I'm doing this. Great. Great. Talk about the process of you guys had looked at a couple of different spaces that had fallen through. I imagine sometimes the price wasn't right, or somebody else came in and... Or the landlord wasn't amenable to what you w- guys wanted to do there. So what I- Or sometimes-

Sometimes what I like to do is sort of get into the inside baseball of how did you do this? For someone who hasn't opened a restaurant or is thinking of just opening a business, what are the pitfalls of it? Don't do it. It is way too much work. It's like, don't do it. I've always wanted to put a restaurant into an old house because I feel like customer service is very big for me, as well as for Matt.

Mm-hmm. It's something that we're actually really gonna focus on in the restaurant. Okay. So similar to, like, Elena's. Is that what you mean by old house? Well, yeah.

Oh, okay. Yeah, yeah. I thought you were talking about customer service. We've talked more at this point about service by far than we've talked about food. Okay. So the idea of putting something into a house where you immediately walk in, you immediately feel comfortable, you immediately feel like you're in someone's home and that you're gonna have a great time and someone's gonna take care of you in that mom or grandmother kind of way always has appealed to me.

Okay. So there was a house over on Washington over kind of by Parsons Children's- Yeah ... Hospital area.

So on the other side of the freeway. Correct. Okay. That I had looked at. But in order to build that out, it was an old house, and so to build it out into a restaurant, it was just gonna be way too much money.

Was it even zoned for that? It was zoned for that- Okay ... actually, yeah. And there were some structural issues, and so passed on that. And then Till was for sale-

Mm-hmm ... last year. Was it last year? Yeah, it was last year. Last year. And w- we got into some pretty heavy negotiations on Till.

Okay. But Blake Compton came in and did a walkthrough and was like, "Don't do it." Okay. And there were some-

Just you knew it was gonna be too much. Yeah. Okay. He was like, "There's a lot of structural issues. There's some issues with the hood system." And also the lease was really shoddy, and it just felt really-

Well, they wanted to continue to own the space, right? No. The original ch- chef's parents owned that building. Ah, okay. And he's, he was selling the building.

Okay. And the lease was, like, super shoddy, and it just came, seemed a little shady. So I passed on that. And so then one day I was at Seven Sun, and Colin Castor came up to me and he was like, "Hey, are you still looking for a restaurant space?" And I said, "Well, as a matter of fact, I am." And he go- he said, "We are opening a sour beer bar on South High." Mm-hmm. "And the space next to us is available for a lease for a restaurant. I really think that you should take a look at it." And he emailed the Kelly brothers, AKA The Property Brothers. They were s- both so handsome.

Okay. They look so much alike. They're like twins that aren't twins. Oh. Yeah.

Like that show. Like The Property Brothers. Okay. Yeah.

I don't watch that show. I didn't- I don't watch it either. I just- I've seen it. Yeah.

Yes. And so he put me in touch with those guys, and the ball just started rolling. Okay. And the price was right and the- The price was right. The lease was, the lease agreement was great. They were really flexible on any changes that we wanted to put in.

Okay. And since the, my food truck has been at Seven Sun for four years- Mm-hmm ... two days a week for four years, I already have a really, really good relationship with them. And Matt also has a really good relationship with them.

Mm-hmm. It just felt right. It felt very symbiotic. Right. Felt like we were gonna have a good partnership without being partners, and that we could really feed off of each other and generate a really good buzz on that corner.

That's great. Yeah. And walk me through where exactly is it? Trying to think what the cross street is, and I can't. Franklin.

It's across the street from Grange Insurance and The Local bar and- So you're south of the Panera? Yeah. Yes.

Okay. About a block south of the Panera. Okay. Next to...

Colacci ... Colacci Republic. Colacci Republic. And there's a Head Shop that went in over there too. So it's that little strip of-

Mm-hmm ... bui- it's not the anti- big antiquers. It is the old antique mall. Oh, okay.

Yeah. Great. Where we're gonna be half of that. And so that's being, that's being sub-sectioned. Yeah.

And so, got it. Now I understand. We'll be on one half, and Seven Sun will be on the other half. Now I understand. Cool. Talk to me more about some of the dishes that you guys expect to be serving. Back to the chicken Parmesan.

Uh-huh. The veal Parmesan. Yeah. So we kinda knew initially that we wanted to figure out some way to do that, if it was gonna be chicken or if it was gonna actually be veal. Mm-hmm.

And we were like, "Well, veal sweetbreads taste exactly like chicken, only the best chicken you've ever had." Right? So we did some playing around, some tinkering with that. We felt like it needed a little bit more acidity to kinda, like, cut through the richness of that. So- Yeah ... started to play around with a raspberry marin- marinara, and then we have, like, a really good thing that we're super happy about. It's, it's beautiful. It's a really, really good dish.

Yeah. We have to get the right cheese or my dad will kill us. Okay. So a lot of the things at the restaurant will be, I'm not gonna say, like, small plates, but tidier portions.

Okay. You know, k- kind of actually meant for everyone. So it's not comfort food. That should not... You don't imagine people would say that to describe it. It's much more Americana. I would, I would say, like, much more Americana.

I think we're gonna be compared to Rockmill, Sycamore. Yeah. But, you know, the food will kinda, like, stand on its own and be its own thing. We're talking about cheese balls, and one of the things we know for sure that we are gonna serve is a comfort food deal, but- Uh-huh ... you'll order, uh, fried chicken, and then someone will bring you a bucket of fried chicken, and then someone will bring you a tray of macaroni and cheese, and then someone will bring you-

Okay ... like, some coleslaw, and then someone will bring you braised green beans, and we're gonna just, like, lay it all the way out. Awesome. So we have some ideas kinda tailored around how some of those dishes made us feel.

Got it. And have you guys done pop-ups yet? We've done two. Okay. I think we've done-

Three ... three. Yeah, like two, two or three. And so you're sorta using that to figure out the menu, um, see what people like, see, get hopefully honest criticism behind it. Not a huge revenue generator, I imagine. No.

No, not huge. More keeping people engaged, I think. Okay. Yeah. Because, you know, like you say, we're gonna open a restaurant in, you know, at that time in over a year.

Right. We just felt like it was best for us to do that as a way to test some things out and try to do some things. Mm-hmm. But also to keep people engaged, like-

Yeah ... "No, this is actually, this is still happening. This is what we're doing." Because that happens a lot People will be like, "Oh, I heard there was gonna be a Stauf's opening here." Right-

And I- 'Cause I'm sure that was a plan at some point I showed up today to get some coffee, and it's not open yet. No, uh, the Stauf's here at the Idea Foundry opens on the 21st.

And it made me really sad, but I didn't... Like, from hearing that there was gonna be a Stauf's open- Right ... to there being a Stauf's open, there's, there's nothing in between. Right.

So we're just trying to, like, maintain something in between. Good. Nice. Smart. So what's your timeline look like right now?

March. Okay. Yeah. So you've got some time.

Which actually is coming up pretty quickly. It is. Well, yeah, it feels like a long time to some people, but to me, it feels like it's a wolf, like, right on my heels. Like, in my head, I'm already in December. I'm like, okay, I'm, like, in December, and then January comes and we get the keys, and then it's go, go, go.

Right. And so what's sort of the build-out plan look like? Like, what do you have to... What has to be arranged in order for you guys to get going? So they actually just finished, like, the baseline demo- Right ... here, uh, a few days ago.

Okay. And they're doing, like, a walkthrough to check our MEP and all our specs, and make sure that everything's gonna work the way, you know, at least in planning. What's MEP? I don't know. It's mechanical something.

Mechanical, electrical- Extra special ... power. Yeah.

Something. Something like that. I don't- Okay ... I don't know the technical term for it. I just know MEP.

I... Yeah, like I, I, I know what they do, I just don't know- Got it ... what it stands for. Okay. Cool. I'll put it in the show notes.

And so what we'll get, hopefully, on the other side of that is an okay to go ahead and white box the space. Okay. You know, drywall. Like- Mm-hmm

... no, no, no finishing touches. There's gonna be an elevation in the kitchen. Okay. There's gonna be, like, a really huge chunk of the kitchen that is, uh- They're tearing down

... designated for, uh, for- Oh, for the- ... ADA ramp. But they're- Then they're tearing down half the building.

Okay. So there's some large things that need to do, uh, need to be done, and then they'll be kinda, like, reassembling it into this nice, tidy package. Gotcha. So while you guys say you're taking over... 'Cause it's a huge... When you said half of it, I was like, that's huge. Yeah.

But- It's gonna be a little bit smaller than probably what you re- Not much. Not much. It's gonna... It's a, it's a decent-sized space, for sure.

How many seats are you looking at? Between 80 and 100. That's a lot. With a patio.

Okay. We're gonna have a patio. That's a lot. And that patio's beautiful.

Awesome. Ugh. Yeah, the renderings are- Oh

... are very exciting. So good-looking. So you guys are working on... You have a permanent pop-up at Three Sheets. Tell me about that. Ambrose & Eve's Burger Shack.

Okay. It's pretty straight up and down, just that. You serve burgers. We serve burgers-

Burgers and, like- ... chicken sandwiches ... classic riffs on, really, our favorite junk food to eat, like jalapeno poppers and Funyuns and potato skins. Okay.

It kinda jumped out at one of our pop-ups. We had a junk food pop-up. Okay. We were, like, kind of already talking about doing this pop-up at Three Sheets, and we were like, "Well, we should just keep this food, 'cause it's really good." So is it technically a pop-up anymore if you're semi-permanent?

I would say that- I think it's a pop, I think it's a pop-up if you don't own it. Yeah. Okay. There you go.

Yeah. Um- 'Cause you don't... So wait, would technically Hala at- Woodlands ... Woodlands be considered a pop-up?

I think so, yeah. Okay. There you go. All right. Where's Three Sheets? It's, uh, next to the Hy-Vee on South High, very close to where our restaurant's gonna be. 560 South High Street.

Yeah. Okay. And w- part of the reason why we wanted to be in that neighborhood is so we could generate buzz and- Get to know people

... get the neighborhood f- familiar with our style and, like- Yeah ... things that they can expect at Ambrose & Eve the restaurant, even though the style's gonna be completely different- Right

... food. But still, like- But the attention that's paid to it is the same. Yeah. You know? It's like-

Well, and it's interesting. I think you guys are slowly but surely br- building a brand up. Oh, for sure. Yeah, because, I mean, that's, I shouldn't say end goal, but that's the goal. Like, that's the way through. Mm-hmm.

We wanna open a few restaurants, and we don't wanna, like, open this restaurant and then open another of the same restaurant, and then another of the same restaurant. We'd like to own a variety of restaurants, uh, that do different things and are all interesting, but have kind of a s- similar underlying aesthetic. You guys are the future Cameron Mitchells. I wouldn't compare us to him, but yes. Fair. Fair. Have you reached out to the... Is it Klatsche?

Klatsche Republic. Klatsche Republic guys. I actually went to high school with that guy. My mom and his mom- With which one?

Klatshu. Okay. My mom and his mom taught high school together, or junior high together. No kidding.

Yeah. So I lived right next door in high school to Dustin. Did you? Not high school, college.

Oh, okay. When I was at Ohio State- Oh, really? ... we, we both lived, like, off of King Avenue.

Oh, that's so funny. Yeah. I've been in twice- Uh-huh

... since we've been kicking around in that neighborhood, and I enjoyed my food a lot. But I feel like they have a lot of regulars. Like, like- Yeah ... the people that came in around me, like, while I was there, everybody was, like, greeted on a first-name basis. Okay.

They, they, they walked in the door and they knew what they were gonna eat. So there's a testament to that. Yeah. That's huge. And customer service is such a big deal that I feel like a lot of restaurants and businesses fail on on a regular basis. Yeah. Well, and what's interesting, what I've seen sort of is as we had that big sort of, I don't wanna call it a renaissance, but, like, everything got really good really fast. Places like Curio and Sycamore and, like, all came up. And then some places, I am not gonna name which ones, you go back, you know, maybe even... It took a couple years, but a couple years later it's like, oh, there's not as much, like, they don't wanna tell you about what's in it because maybe they don't know or maybe they're too busy, and there's not as much focus on the customer service end of things.

I think that's fully fair to say. I completely agree. Well, okay. Yeah.

Have you seen that? Oh, absolutely. Okay. And that's, like, why Matt and I have had so many conversations on customer service, continued education with the servers.

Yeah. Like, wine education, spirit education, food education, so that they can answer the questions, they can tell you where it came from. They know what's in it. Like- Well, and they're exci- and they need to be excited ... and they're excited about it. Like, they-

'Cause the problem is- Yeah ... is those people who are super good at customer service and, like, take extra time and, like, train themselves and read books, and I'm thinking about more, like, alcohol and beer at this point- Who, like, wanna talk to the customer about, like, what is a sour beer or what makes a lager. And those people actually, because they're so good, they get promoted to management. Mm-hmm.

And then the people that come in under them don't take the time or as passionate, and they're just sort of like, "This is my job to sling beers or drinks or whatever it is." And yeah, I mean, that really does differentiate a business to me. Well, I, I think, um, I think part of that is people are going to college, and they're like, "I'm just serving and this is just like my part-time job-" Right ... while I work on my degree." But people are maybe not ashamed isn't the right word, but, like, it's okay to be a professional server.

Yeah. That, that can be your career, and it's a- Like a restaurant professional? Yeah.

Like, that is a real thing. Absolutely it is. And when you go other places, you see that. Like- Right

... even here in DC. Like New York, LA, like- Yeah ... that's, that's totally a thing there.

Well- But there are pe- I'm, so, like, I'm thinking, first of all, uh, while we may be snarky about it sometimes, the Cameron Mitchell restaurants do a really good job of at least having a baseline- I completely agree with that ... of great customer service.

They attract people. They take care of people. Yeah. They take care- Well-

... of their staff extremely well. Like, I will say that I admire his business motto and the way that he takes care of customers- Mm-hmm ... and the way he takes care of guests. It's great. Yeah.

Like, absolutely it's great. That milkshake thing and whatever. What? Do you know about the milkshake thing?

No. So if you ever go into a Cameron Mitchell restaurant, some of the servers or host staff or managers have a l- a little lapel pin that is a milkshake, and it's representative of going into a place and saying, "Hey, all I want is a milkshake," and there's no milkshake on the menu. And the, and the standard should be if you have the things you need to make a milkshake, just make them a milkshake rather than, you know, having to dec- what's the... There's a movie where the guy wants to order a BLT, and there's all the ingredients for the BLT are on- Oh, yeah. What is that movie? Is it Jack Nicholson is in that scene?

I don't... I, I know what you're talking about, but I don't recall the- I will put that in the show notes as well. But it's basically just the philosophy, give them what they want. And now that I think about it, it's sort of the established places like Barcelona, the places that have been in Columbus for, like, 20 years or 30 years, I don't know how long they've been here, and Tapatio was when it was still around, was those are career servers, and so they're passionate about what they- Lindy's has a lot of career servers. Lindy's, great example as well. Yeah.

Yeah. So- We're hoping to attract those people. Literally.

Yeah. 'Cause we'll also come up- Come and work for Ambrose and Eve. So we're gonna offer profit sharing for our-

So that's part of your model? Correct. Yeah, okay. Yeah.

So yeah, I mean- Have you worked out how that's gonna look exactly? Eh, we've talked about it, but we don't have anything I would say in, like, finite details as of- Okay

... yet, but it's- So basically what you guys will do is say employees have X percentage of ownership of the company. Mm-hmm. It's not necessarily that they're not gonna get vested or anything.

Right. But, but while they work there, what, every quarter, every- We'll pay down a percentage of the restaurant's profits. Okay.

Kind of a scale across employees to management. And that'll be based on hours worked, I assume, plus seniority. Hours worked, seniority. Okay.

We just feel like it will really incentivize people to do a good job- Yeah ... to be professional. To take care in it 'cause th- the- essentially, like, that restaurant is also theirs in a way-

Right ... so they'll treat it like it's their own, it's, it's their own space, so. Do you feel like you're gonna have to open up your books a little bit and sort of say, like, "Here's what... Here's how we're doing-" I-

... basically I think that's what that is going to be. Mm-hmm. I'm just super curious 'cause I, as a somebody who's done, who's been involved in a restaurant space sort of passively and then also as somebody who's consulted on, like, bar marketing and stuff, I always get sort of an itch when somebody's like, "I'm gonna spend this amount of money on this," and I haven't been asked about it, and I'm like, "That seems like a lot of money to spend on Wi-Fi," or, "Seems like a lot of money to spend on ca- like, commercial cable for a restaurant or a bar is crazy expensive." It's really expensive.

It's really expensive. We don't want we don't want TVs. Well, yeah, but it's, it's stuff like that, and I just wonder if, and this is totally just me thinking things through, is do you have a risk of the employees then being like, "Why are we spending so much money on veal?" Do you worry you're gonna open yourself up to that? I guess I'm just wondering- I, I never- ... if you've thought about it

... I never worried about it. Okay. I, I don't really. That's why I kinda, like, stepped back a bit from employee owners- Okay

... to profit sharing. Like, those are not the same thing. Yes, absolutely. Or, or they don't have to be the same things. They can be. Right.

So we make- It's basically bonuses. Yeah. I mean-

Performance-based bonuses. Yeah. Absolutely. Exactly, and I mean, you guys aren't gonna put yourselves out, but yeah, it's based on the success of the space.

And it's tied directly to all of our performance. Mm-hmm. From how we implement our ideas into the kitchen to how people execute them- Mm-hmm

... to how our GM runs the flow of service to how, you know, individual servers and bartenders, like, execute it. Mm-hmm. How we manage our labor, how we manage our food costs. Right. How are you guys splitting, as business partners, how are you sort of splitting up your duties?

Well, so- What's your role? Generally, generally, because I am a little bit more of a night owl and she likes to get moving a little bit more during the day- Mm-hmm

... she'll be more or less in charge of what's going on during the day, and I'll be more or less in charge of what's going on at night. Okay. You know, we'll meet, like, all of the food that we put out will be, will be our food, and we'll test all the recipes together. Okay.

We'll train people to implement them together. Exactly the same way. There won't be any differences. Got it. Which is important.

Yeah. I think that's very important. Consistency, yeah. Consistency, and we, we are on the same page with that in the Burger Shack right now. Like, before I send anything out, I ask Matt if he's okay with it, and he does the same with me as well-

Mm-hmm ... because I think there's a mutual level of respect that we have for each other- Mm-hmm ... each other's opinions, and also, like, we wanna be successful, so we wanna run... It's better to have two eyes-

Right ... four eyes- They both have glasses Eight eyes.

Uh-huh. Eight eyes in the kitchen than, than none, so, like, yeah. Right. So what about, like, I'm just curious about, like, what about accounting? What about payroll? What about- I think it's a really good idea to-

Hire someone ... do the things that you are good at. Yep. And hire people to do the things that you are not great at.

Again, having done this before, I'm just curious, what have you identified at this point of, like, mm, we probably need a lawyer sometimes, or- Well- ... like, we need an accountant ... so a lawyer, a bookkeeper, an accountant.

Mm-hmm. Are those separate? Yes. Okay. Bookkeepers-

Day-to-day ... that's actually the difference. Like, day-to-day- Uh-huh ... bookkeepers are much less expensive.

Yep. And what they do is they kinda, like, collate things. They- They keep everything ... they file receipts. They put things into, into spreadsheets.

Yeah. And then your accountant does the heavy lifting. The taxes. That type of thing.

Right. Yeah. And the bookkeeper could easily be the general manager, too. Yeah.

I mean- Absolutely. It's just somebody who has that skill set and knows how to work QuickBooks or whatever you guys decide on using. Yeah. So.

Yeah. Cool. You're gonna have beer and liquor, or- Yes. Awesome. Congratulations.

We're gonna focus on ciders. Okay. We feel like people's idea of cider is very American right now. Yeah. It's like, what?

It's the- Angry Orchard? Like, ooh, Angry Orchard. Yeah. There are, like, eight Angry Orchards, though.

Right. So- But you will have a sort of a depth and breadth of a, of a cider menu. Yeah. Liquor?

Yeah. Yes. We'll have liquor. Okay, great. So you'll have some cocktails. You'll have-

And then we'll have a couple of draft, and then we'll... W- we're gonna have a couple of drafts. We're gonna have- Literally, like, two. We're gonna... Yeah. That's cheaper-

Yeah ... for implementation. I mean- Well, the space is limited. Right.

So, I mean- Well, like, it's a pretty big space, but there are two walls in the middle of that- Okay ... restaurant that cannot move because they're holding the building up.

They're load-bearing, right. Okay. Everyone's a- So, and then the, we have a lead-lined room. Uh- Oh, it was a bank.

Oh. Or something. Yeah. Or something.

So that can't come down either, so. So, you know, like, it, it would be cost-prohibitive to do anything with that. Right. So those things kinda, like, pinch our space, and then some of the space in the room where we're gonna put the bar is being co-opted for a flight of stairs to go upstairs to the apartment that's upstairs.

Okay. So there are so many, like, really, really good local craft beers that are available in bottles and cans- Yeah. Thankfully ... uh, right now that we feel like we can still manage a really good selection, but-

You gonna keep PBR tall boys there for me, or- I mean, I almost feel like you have- Only if you stock them. Well, maybe...

We'll keep them in the kitchen. Okay. It'll be a kitchen beer you can buy for the kitchen. Got it.

And the, and there'll be an excellent for you. Yeah. Thank you. Any-

I appreciate that ... anytime, anytime. Guys, thank you so much for coming in again. Thanks for having us.

Is there a website that I can link to? We're working on it. Matthew Hagans, Katie Randazzo, Ambrose and Eve, thank you guys so much for coming in. Thank you.

Thank you for listening to the Confluence Cast presented by Columbus Underground. Again, you can get more information on what we discussed today in the show notes for this episode at theconfluencecast.com. Please rate, subscribe, share this episode of the Confluence Cast with your friends, family, contacts, enemies, your favorite restaurateur. If you're interested in sponsoring the Confluence Cast, get in touch with us. We can be reached by email at info@theconfluencecast.com. Our theme music was composed by Benji Robinson. I'm your host, Tim Fulton. Have a great week.

Transcript10,766 words

Tim Fulton Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the Confluence Cast presented by Columbus Underground. We are a weekly Columbus-centric podcast focusing on the civics, lifestyle, entertainment, and people of our city. I'm your host, Tim Fulton. This week, on the occasion of Dine Originals Week coming up September 18th through 24th, I sat down with Shelley Mann, Dine Originals Columbus' executive director, to talk about the organization, some of the restaurants you can check out during Dine Originals Week, and we talk about Shelley's work doing public relations in Columbus. And in a bonus interview, I spoke with the founders of the restaurant Ambrose and Eve, slated to open in German Village next year. You can get more information on what we discussed today in the show notes for this episode at theconfluencecast.com. Also, the Confluence Cast is on Patreon. Find out how to support this podcast on our website, theconfluencecast.com, or at patreon.com/confluence. Enjoy the interviews. Sitting down here with Shelley Mann, the executive director of Dine Originals Columbus. Shelley, how are you?

Shelley Mann I'm great. How are you?

Tim Fulton I'm doing well. Coming up towards the end of September, September 18th through 24th, we are sitting down here on the occasion of Dine Originals Week. The 35 Dine Originals restaurants will be offering prix fixe three-course menus, uh, for a fixed price. That's what prix fixe means. To customers to basically come and check out their restaurant. Shelley, tell us what is Dine Originals?

Shelley Mann Yeah. Dine Originals is a nonprofit organization. It's been around for over a decade, and really, the, the goal is to provide a group of independent restaurants in Columbus to sort of band together-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... and really talk about, you know, what are the benefits of eating, uh, dining out at your independent restaurants.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So we're really helping to market and promote our city's independent restaurant scene and trying to educate diners on why it's important to support these restaurants and keep the money in our community, as opposed to choosing a chain restaurant when you're going out to eat.

Tim Fulton Gotcha. And so-

Shelley Mann Yeah

Tim Fulton ... by virtue of them banding together, they can focus their marketing efforts together.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton A big, big part of that is Dine Originals Week.

Shelley Mann Mm-hmm.

Tim Fulton You guys also every May do an event called Taste of Dine Originals at Franklin Park. So what, as a consumer, what do you offer me?

Shelley Mann Well, yeah, so we are-- One of our main ways that we bring in revenue is we sell gift certificates to the consumers-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... through our website. And so we collect gift certificates from all of our member restaurants, and then we sell those back to the customer at 30% off face value.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So we do our sales four times a year, so it's a quarterly sale.

Tim Fulton Oh, so you can't just go on at any time.

Shelley Mann Well, you can, but-

Tim Fulton Depending on if they're available.

Shelley Mann Yeah. So-

Tim Fulton They sell out

Shelley Mann ... the popular ones sell out-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... right away. And then-

Tim Fulton Who sell-- I'm not gonna-- Let's not talk about who doesn't sell out, but who does sell out quickly?

Shelley Mann Oh, man. So, you know, The Refectory, theirs sell out really quickly.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann Skillet.

Tim Fulton What's the price point? Like-

Shelley Mann Barcelona

Tim Fulton ... is it, like, 50 bucks, 100, or?

Shelley Mann We have different price points. So we have some that are $50 gift certificates, and you can buy them for $35.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And then we have $25 gift certificates that you can buy for $17.50. And then we have some that are $10 gift certificates that you can buy for $7.50.

Tim Fulton I see.

Shelley Mann So we have all different prices.

Tim Fulton And that depends on the restaurant and the price point-

Shelley Mann Yes

Tim Fulton ... that the restaurant is. And they're not trying to-- They don't set a point where it's like, "Oh, it's only $10, and our average meal is $12." It doesn't really happen that way, right?

Shelley Mann No.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann They can choose what denomination they wanna sell.

Tim Fulton I see.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton And when does that sale happen?

Shelley Mann Those happen every year. So our, our most recent one ha- launched the first week of August.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And then-

Tim Fulton Still some stuff on there.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann There's still some stuff on there to check out. And then we'll have our next one in November, the first week of November. So it's, generally, it's the first week of February, May, August, November.

Tim Fulton Gotcha.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton And the, does the November one tend to be more popular because-

Shelley Mann It does

Tim Fulton ... people-

Shelley Mann Holiday shopping.

Tim Fulton Right. Well- ... and you don't-- The gift card doesn't say, "I bought this for 30% off."

Shelley Mann That's true.

Tim Fulton There you go.

Shelley Mann Yes.

Tim Fulton Save 30% on your gifts this November. Talk about Dine Originals Week and sort of what some of the participating restaurants are. What's the price range of the menus?

Shelley Mann Yeah. So Dine Originals Week, actually, this is a fun fact for you. Dine Originals Week was Columbus' first Restaurant Week.

Tim Fulton I remember when it was the only- ... Restaurant Week.

Shelley Mann So yeah, when Dine Originals was founded, it was really founded by the restaurants. They-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... they banded together. And at that time, there was a national Dine Originals organization.

Tim Fulton Oh, okay.

Shelley Mann So there would be Dine Originals groups in different cities across the country.

Tim Fulton Is that not a national organization?

Shelley Mann It's actually, it's not a national organization anymore. There are still chapters in some cities.

Tim Fulton Do you consider yourself a chapter of it? Were you part of the larger organization?

Shelley Mann We were part of the larger-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... organization. So the larger organization does not exist, so we're not technically a chapter. We did form into our own nonprofit organization after-

Tim Fulton Gotcha

Shelley Mann ... the national organization disbanded.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann But, you know, at the time that Dine Originals was created, Restaurant Weeks were kind of a new concept.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And, you know, a really exciting way to get people going out to eat-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... on slow time, during slow times of the year for the restaurants.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann So that's why we do them in, we do ours in March and September.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And, you know, we're really trying to get people to come in on week, on weeknights as well.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann So, you know, the special runs through the weekend, but restaurants a lot of times are, you know, struggling to get people in on the weeknights of these times of year.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann So our Restaurant Week, we took a little hiatus-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... and then we brought it back starting last year. And so we do these, like I said, twice a year.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And all of our restaurants offer... Generally, they're three-course menus, and you get them for the fixed price point.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So you know, you know what you're gonna pay going in. Our menus range in price from $15 up to $40.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And the restaurants can decide-

Tim Fulton What's like a $40 restaurant?

Shelley Mann The Refectory, uh, theirs is actually $39.50.

Tim Fulton Oh. Okay.

Shelley Mann I don't know if anyone has exactly 40. Yeah, so they're, you know, like some of the higher-end restaurants are doing the $40.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Shelley Mann And then someone like Chile Verde Cafe-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... theirs is in the $15-

Tim Fulton Gotcha

Shelley Mann ... price range.

Tim Fulton And so you're getting three courses, so you're getting like-

Shelley Mann Right

Tim Fulton ... an appetizer or salad or soup portion-

Shelley Mann Mm-hmm

Tim Fulton ... a main course, and then a dessert tends to be-

Shelley Mann Typically, yeah.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Shelley Mann And the menus are all different, so, you know, it's, it's, it can be really fun to kinda poke through. We put them all online on our website. So some of the restaurants, you'll do-

Tim Fulton And plug the website for me

Shelley Mann ... dineoriginalscolumbus.com.

Tim Fulton And that will be linked in the show notes as well. Go on.

Shelley Mann So some of the restaurants will do something like, you know, a soup and salad, and then an appetizer, and then a main course, or, you know. So some of them don't include a dessert, or maybe you get, like, two kinda main coursey type things.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So they're all different, and they're all really interesting-

Tim Fulton Cool

Shelley Mann ... just to kinda look through. But, and generally, you know, for the Restaurant Week, the chef is doing something a little more creative.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann He or she are working in seasonal ingredients.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann Um, so this time around it's, you know, there's a lot of wild game meat and-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... you know, warmer soups and kinda l- turning towards the fall.

Tim Fulton So while the items are typical of the restaurant, these are special items.

Shelley Mann Yes.

Tim Fulton Gotcha.

Shelley Mann So they're definitely things that you can only get during Restaurant Week, so it's another reason to go out and check these menus out.

Tim Fulton Great. How does a restaurant join Dine Originals? What are the, the requirements?

Shelley Mann Yeah, the requirements are you have to be independently owned and operated.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So that means, you know, you're the-

Tim Fulton McDonald's cannot join

Shelley Mann ... owner that works in there. Yeah, no, any chain restaurant cannot join.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann If you're owned by, you know, a, a company that owns many other restaurants-

Tim Fulton Or you're a franchisor.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann So you have to have six locations or less-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... as well. So we do have some local chains who still count.

Tim Fulton What's an example of that?

Shelley Mann Well, Chile Verde Cafe does have two locations-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... so that's an example. The Wine Bistro is-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... I remember they have right now three locations.

Tim Fulton I didn't realize they were-

Shelley Mann The Wine Bistro

Tim Fulton ... locally owned and operated.

Shelley Mann They are. And they actually just bought Catsingers.

Tim Fulton Really?

Shelley Mann Which means that they have four locations.

Tim Fulton Is that news?

Shelley Mann No.

Tim Fulton When did that happen?

Shelley Mann Hmm, last year.

Tim Fulton Okay. But someone like Cameron Mitchell, while there may only be two Cap City Diners-

Shelley Mann Right

Tim Fulton ... he owns a significant number of-

Shelley Mann Yeah

Tim Fulton ... restaurants.

Shelley Mann So he has The Pearl-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... The Old House. He probably has six in Short North.

Tim Fulton Yeah. Well, he probably has six in one block in the Short North. Listen to my interview with Katie Randazzo later for- ... more digs and yet respect of Cameron Mitchell. Cool. And so what do they have to... How do they... Are they contributing a check? How do they-

Shelley Mann No. Yeah

Tim Fulton ... how do they join?

Shelley Mann So our dues are actually those gift certificates that I just mentioned.

Tim Fulton Oh, okay.

Shelley Mann So it's actually an easy way for a restaurant to, to join something like this because they're re- they're donating gift certificates to the restaurant.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann We sell them on their behalf. So it's-

Tim Fulton So they're actually, uh, they're not even giving you anything.

Shelley Mann No.

Tim Fulton They're allowing you to-

Shelley Mann To sell the certificate

Tim Fulton ... to sell, rather collect revenue.

Shelley Mann Right.

Tim Fulton But then they honor the gift cards.

Shelley Mann They honor the gift card.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Shelley Mann So they don't get any money when you bring in the gift card in.

Tim Fulton Gotcha. So-

Shelley Mann But typically, you know-

Tim Fulton ... make sure you're tipping

Shelley Mann ... yes. Please make sure you're tipping heavily.

Tim Fulton Yes.

Shelley Mann And a lot of times, you know, especially if it's a $10 gift card, I mean, you're probably spending more money when you go in-

Tim Fulton Got it

Shelley Mann ... than just the $10.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Shelley Mann So, you know, we're helping to bring new, new customers into the restaurants that might not go in otherwise. We're helping to fill seats that might be empty otherwise-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... for the restaurants. So there are a lot of benefits for the restaurant to joining and in doing our gift certificate program.

Tim Fulton And then, so how did you get here? What's your- I, I sort of know this story, but what's your background that brought you to Dine Originals?

Shelley Mann Yeah, so I started out in journalism-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... and I was working for The Dispatch printing company.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And I-

Tim Fulton So this is the time in the episode where gonna give my full disclosure that you and I- ... used to work together tangentially-

Shelley Mann Yes, at Alive

Tim Fulton ... for The Alive. Right.

Shelley Mann Right. Yeah, so when I was at Alive, the, you know, higher-ups at The Dispatch started talking about wanting to start a food magazine.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And I was on some of the early committees and talking about the food magazine, which became Crave.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And-

Tim Fulton Is Crave still around?

Shelley Mann No-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... sadly. So and then-

Tim Fulton My, how many ancillary products we've seen come and go.

Shelley Mann And I ended up being able to be the first editor of Crave when it launched.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann So that was a magazine covering the restaurant scene in Columbus.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And once The Dispatch was purchased by GateHouse... Gate- GateHouse, right? Yeah.

Tim Fulton GateHouse Media, yeah.

Shelley Mann They did close down both Crave and Capital Style, unfortunately, but-

Tim Fulton Oh, that's when it happened.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Oh, okay.

Shelley Mann But yeah, so I was writing stories about the restaurant scene for my, for my job back then, and I got to know a lot of the chefs and owners-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... and things like that. And so I actually, for ve- a lot of different reasons, I decided to leave the journalism world-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... and start my own company, which is called Umami Consulting.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And I was... I still do Umami as well, but so I-

Tim Fulton You can hire her

Shelley Mann ... work with independent restaurants and help them with marketing and PR efforts.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So what I was seeing when I was interviewing these chefs and owners is that a lot of the independent restaurants, you know, they don't have, they don't have the budget to hire someone specifically dedicated-

Tim Fulton To do marketing

Shelley Mann ... to doing marketing.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann And so they're doing it themselves and, you know, the owner is doing the marketing, or the chef is doing the marketing, and they don't really have the time or capacity to do that.

Tim Fulton They wanna be running a business, right?

Shelley Mann Yeah. So being able to offer, you know, packages designed for restaurants-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... to help them tell their story-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... was, seemed like a need in the city, and it c- It has been, you know

Tim Fulton What do those packages look like? Is it like, what's the low end? Not price point- ... but what do you actually offer on the low end?

Shelley Mann Yeah, I mean, so like a low end would be a-

Tim Fulton One press release for-

Shelley Mann ... a PR. Yeah

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... like a PR package where, you know, a- anytime you're having a special event or something that you-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... wanna spread the word on, you would call me up and I would write a press release for you and send it to all the local media outlets-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... and-

Tim Fulton And you do some follow up and-

Shelley Mann ... get it on the calendars and-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Shelley Mann ... yeah, try to get you media coverage.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Shelley Mann So that would be a low end. And then for some of my clients that I'm working with, I do everything from helping them with purchasing ads-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... figuring out where are the best places to spend their ad money and, you know, h- how big their ad, you know, should be, and then designing the ads for them.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Shelley Mann Coming up with ideas for marketing campaigns and promotions, and then-

Tim Fulton And even helping organize events then.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann Organizing events, I do a lot of that. And then, you know, social media, that kind of thing-

Tim Fulton Gotcha

Shelley Mann ... I can also help with.

Tim Fulton Makes sense.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Can we talk about the movie?

Shelley Mann Wait a second. We can.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann But let me j- say how I got to Dine Originals-

Tim Fulton Okay. Finish that

Shelley Mann ... finish the story.

Tim Fulton Sure.

Shelley Mann So I was doing Umami and then Dine Originals approached me when their previous executive director left-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... Catherine Moore.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann And asked if I could take on the executive director role, and it actually, it fits in really nicely with what I'm doing already.

Tim Fulton Yeah, absolutely.

Shelley Mann So it's really just about marketing and, and doing, you know, public relations work for the independent restaurant scene. And so a lot of my clients are actually were Dine Originals restaurants and are Dine Originals restaurants, so.

Tim Fulton Gotcha.

Shelley Mann Yeah, so it was a really good fit. And so I do, this is just a part-time job for me, but-

Tim Fulton Got it. That's great. So, and part of your sort of freelance and contract marketing efforts, you actually worked, uh, with the, what's his name?

Shelley Mann Morgan Spurlock.

Tim Fulton You actually worked with Morgan Spurlock's company when he came into town and did that little pop-up joke restaurant for the movie that... It hasn't come out yet, right?

Shelley Mann It's premiering this month at the Toronto Film Festival.

Tim Fulton Okay. So it's-

Shelley Mann I don't know when that starts

Tim Fulton ... it's doing the festival circuit.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Can you talk about that experience and what it was like? What's the name of the film?

Shelley Mann It's, I guess it's gonna be called, uh, Super Size Me 2.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann Holy Chicken!

Tim Fulton Holy Chicken! And Holy Chicken! was the name of the pop-up restaurant up in Westerville. So the press surrounding it, to be clear, your role was literally public relations for this.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton That-

Shelley Mann Lo- local public relations. Yeah

Tim Fulton ... local public relations. So your job was to convey to the media that this thing was happening, that Morgan Spurlock was behind it, and you did that. You were paid to do that. And so you sent out press releases, you contacted television stations, you actually did some outreach to city officials, correct?

Shelley Mann Correct.

Tim Fulton And so there was some backlash there because even though the name Morgan Spurlock was attached to it, everybody just got all, I think Columbus does this too much, got all sort of excited about a famous person being here and said, "Isn't this great? Everything must be on the up and up. This i- this isn't a joke. No one's making fun of us." And I... And so give us the rundown basically on what Holy Chicken!, what that pop-up restaurant was.

Shelley Mann Yeah. It's not a joke. I mean, I, I still stand by that statement.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So, and I have not seen the movie, so I-

Tim Fulton Okay

Shelley Mann ... I, I, you know, I'm looking forward to seeing it and, and seeing how everything-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... turns out to be portrayed. But yeah, so what happened is the Morgan Spurlock's team-

Tim Fulton Mm

Shelley Mann ... film team contacted me just through, uh, Googling, like-

Tim Fulton Columbus restaurant PR

Shelley Mann ... Columbus restaurant marketing.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann PR. And so I came on as a, as a, you know, a, a paid, like-

Tim Fulton You were a consultant

Shelley Mann ... consultant-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... for this project. And yeah, exactly what you said. You know, I, we, we shared the information that there, it was going to be a pop-up restaurant-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... brought to you by Morgan Spurlock, you know, documentary filmmaker.

Tim Fulton Of, of Super Size Me fame.

Shelley Mann Right. And he's trying something different out, which we were very specific in describing the, um, the sourcing of the chicken.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And used, you know, exactly the words that he wanted to use and-

Tim Fulton Okay. Wait, so even the press release was like, what's the, the halo of health?

Shelley Mann Yeah, exactly.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann So, you know, I think, uh, like nothing was ever false, nothing was ever... Everything that we said was exactly what you got when you got to the restaurant.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann So, you know, it's like people hear the word-

Tim Fulton Fresh

Shelley Mann ... fresh, farm fresh.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann And they assume that it's something-

Tim Fulton That it's healthy. Right

Shelley Mann ... specific. And yeah, you assume that it's, that it's healthy, even though we actually, you know, like gave ahead of time the calorie information for the sandwich-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... which was absolutely not healthy.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann Like, it was more calories than a Big Mac.

Tim Fulton Well, it's why people perceive that you go to Chipotle and you're eating a 2,000-calorie burrito and that-

Shelley Mann Right

Tim Fulton ... that, that, that is somehow good for you.

Shelley Mann Right.

Tim Fulton It's not. You're engorging yourself on food.

Shelley Mann Exactly. And then, you know, the, the words that we use to talk about the, the farm that the chickens were raised on are exactly the words that anyone's legally allowed to use-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... to, to describe the situation that these chickens were raised in, which-

Tim Fulton But they're not anything special.

Shelley Mann No, it's not. You know, I think y- what people-

Tim Fulton They're not

Shelley Mann ... have in mind if they hear farm fresh, farm raised chickens-

Tim Fulton All chickens are raised on farms

Shelley Mann ... and free-range. Yeah.

Tim Fulton All chickens are raised on farms. Right.

Shelley Mann Is that they have access to, you know, an area that's just, it just needs to be a few feet by a few feet, that if they can make it out of, you know, this chicken coop that they're in-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... then yeah, they can, they can graze.

Tim Fulton Call it free range. Well, and that's sort of-

Shelley Mann But it's not the pasture raised that you're imagining when you hear-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... those words.

Tim Fulton Well, and that's the whole point of the film is-

Shelley Mann Yeah

Tim Fulton ... sort of pointing out-

Shelley Mann The whole point was that.

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann And the whole point is actually much bigger than that. And so, you know, what this was, wa- was just talking about the rest- the restaurant part of it.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann And actually, the goal through the restaurant was to figure out if, if, like, is there a better way to do this? Is there a better model? And as far as I know, I'm not in direct contact with Morgan's team.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann I get asked-

Tim Fulton Your contract is done

Shelley Mann ... on a, a regular basis. But yes, I was just hired to do the promotion for the Holy Chicken Take- uh, Pop-Up Restaurant-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... that happened last year. But from what I hear, there actually still are plans to open a Holy Chicken franchise.

Tim Fulton Okay .

Shelley Mann And you know-

Tim Fulton So-

Shelley Mann ... after the movie comes out. So there, there was nothing really-

Tim Fulton So we're-

Shelley Mann ... joke or a hoax-

Tim Fulton What we're burying here-

Shelley Mann ... about this whole thing, but-

Tim Fulton So you ... So once you went into the restaurant, again-

Shelley Mann Yeah

Tim Fulton ... the mayor showed up. You know, every television station showed up. You actually transferred, you came to my house and transferred- ... with a, a production assistant to get the footage from the news station, so I imagine that will be in the film. When you go, though, to the restaurant, there are sort of snarky sayings pointing out to you, "Hey, this is this many calories," and, "Hey, this water is actually just Columbus tap water, and it's probably the healthiest thing that you can have here." And so the news crews, everybody shows up, and I think they felt duped be- but that's actually the point.

Shelley Mann Right. I mean-

Tim Fulton But the problem is, is they actually, they, they felt duped, but they still went ahead and did a normal, quote-unquote, this famous person is doing a pop-up, and didn't talk about what he was trying to prove because they couldn't... 'cause it's difficult to put that into a four-minute news story.

Shelley Mann Well, yeah, exactly. I mean, I think you probably need a two-hour movie to-

Tim Fulton Exactly

Shelley Mann ... really explain the whole thing.

Tim Fulton Yeah, and I don't think we're even properly explaining it, but I think the, the, the point I wanna make is you actually got in hot water with your media contacts because they were like, "How could we possibly ever trust you again?" And it's like, I didn't lie to you. I literally just transferred information. I was hired because I know you, and Morgan, and you ate, literally ate it up. And I just th- I, I would hope that those relationships are on the mend at this point, and everybody's sort of like, "Oh, I get it. This isn't Shelley's, quote-unquote, fault." I just think it's an interesting ... We as a city need to be a little bit... We should certainly continue to be smart and open, but we need to be a little bit less starstruck- ... when things happen, so.

Shelley Mann Yeah. Yeah. The whole situation, I mean, it's, it's... I've never experienced anything quite like it.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Shelley Mann You know, I hope that-

Tim Fulton Do you regret it?

Shelley Mann ... people... I'd like to see the movie, movie before I-

Tim Fulton Make a decision about that

Shelley Mann ... will tell you if I regret it or not.

Tim Fulton Are you in the movie, do you think?

Shelley Mann But I would say not. I, I don't know.

Tim Fulton Were you on camera much?

Shelley Mann Yeah. I mean, I was on... There were cameras in the restaurant the entire weekend, and I was there the entire weekend, so.

Tim Fulton But you were never, like, interviewed and asked-

Shelley Mann No

Tim Fulton ... like, "How'd you... Did you dupe these people?"

Shelley Mann No.

Tim Fulton Or any-

Shelley Mann No.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Shelley Mann No, no, no. No, and you know, I think that my hope right afterwards is that everyone, you know, would believe me when I say that I would never do anything to harm Columbus or, you know-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... if, if they asked me to do, to take this on, like, "Hey, we have this project where we're going to trick the city of Columbus into eating something that they didn't agree to eat," I would've said no.

Tim Fulton No, I'm not interested.

Shelley Mann You know? Like, no way. So you know, the, the, the bigger mission behind the restaurant in terms of I think that when you go into a restaurant and you read a menu, you should understand what you're getting. And, you know, if you go into the grocery store and you see free-range eggs and you pay, like, $3 more than you would for the carton next to it, that you should be getting a better product.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann I mean, that's what really-

Tim Fulton And realizing that it's not necessar- It may be a slightly better product, but-

Shelley Mann Yeah

Tim Fulton ... you need to be an educated consumer and, and know what that value is.

Shelley Mann Right.

Tim Fulton And that value, I would hope, isn't just associated with marketing lang-

Shelley Mann Marketing, right

Tim Fulton ... marketing language.

Shelley Mann Exactly.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Shelley Mann So you know, the whole, the bigger concept is something that I really stand behind.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Shelley Mann And I hope that the movie can make a difference in that way.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Shelley Mann And so in that way, no, I don't regret it. And I, you know, yeah, like I said, I mean, I, I was really hired to do a job, which I did, which is-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Shelley Mann ... get people to come out to the pop-up restaurant. You know, I, I think what Morgan's goal... You know, he wanted people to come out and experience it and not kinda get the, you know, the-

Tim Fulton Not get what he was doing to them.

Shelley Mann Yeah, like not-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Shelley Mann ... you know, like read an article that explains exactly what it was-

Tim Fulton Exactly

Shelley Mann ... and then feel like you don't have to go because you get it now.

Tim Fulton You get the joke, right.

Shelley Mann So he wanted people to come out and experience it, and that's what we did. You know, we got a lot of people out there.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Shelley Mann And a lot of people had a great time. A lot of people really liked eating the food. A lot of people, um-

Tim Fulton 'Cause it wasn't a bad chicken sandwich

Shelley Mann ... understood what was going on.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Shelley Mann No, yeah. The chicken sandwich was great. It, it tasted just as good as, you know, like in-

Tim Fulton Any other chicken sandwich

Shelley Mann ... crazy restaurant chicken sandwich would. Um-

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann So yeah, it was, it was definitely, it was definitely interesting. And yeah, I mean, I will always say, like, as soon as I s- When I send out a press release about a restaurant opening in Columbus-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Shelley Mann ... generally, it's kinda crickets. I mean, you know, like the most we can hope for is, you know, like an article-

Tim Fulton A blurb

Shelley Mann ... in The Dispatch-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... and something on Columbus Underground-

Tim Fulton Right

Shelley Mann ... and you know, something like that, and a review in Alive.

Tim Fulton Right.

Shelley Mann When I sent out a press release saying that Morgan Spurlock is opening a restaurant in Columbus, immediately it was every news outlet called me back.

Tim Fulton Yep.

Shelley Mann So I found that to be just interesting.

Tim Fulton Yeah. We need to stop doing that. So- Cool. Shelley, uh, thank you so much for your time, and again, check out Dine Originals Week, September 18th through 24th.

Shelley Mann Yeah.

Tim Fulton Say thank you.

Shelley Mann Thank you for having me.

Tim Fulton Sitting down here with Matthew Hagens and Katie Randazzo, the chefs and co-owners of Ambrose and Eve. Ambrose and Eve up to this point has been a pop-up experience around Columbus, uh, for sort of a dinner party atmosphere. They are opening up a new permanent space on High Street, just south of...

Katie Randazzo Tremont. Yeah, it's right next to Tremont and, like, Clotches Republic.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And we'll be next to the new Seven Sons Sour Beer Bar that's opening up as well.

Tim Fulton Oh, fantastic. When's that coming?

Katie Randazzo They think they're gonna be open in a couple months.

Tim Fulton Okay. That's ambitious.

Matthew Hagens They're ambitious people.

Tim Fulton We all are.

Katie Randazzo Yeah, that's why we like them.

Tim Fulton We all are. Give me the elevator pitch on Ambrose and Eve.

Katie Randazzo Ambrose and Eve is named after my dad's parents, and what we're trying to build is a-

Matthew Hagens We wanna have a nice, fun dinner party every night.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens And we want you, we want you to feel like you're coming to one of our grandparents or mother's house, and you have a really good time, but at the end of it, you have to help pay for it.

Tim Fulton And I assume that will translate in the atmosphere and also the food. It's not people have to show up at a set time. It is a traditional restaurant.

Matthew Hagens It's a... It's gonna be a very traditional restaurant. The menu will change very frequently based on what's available-

Tim Fulton Okay

Matthew Hagens ... seasonally and the things that we're interested in. We'll be focusing mostly on Americana.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens Trying to update that and make that a little bit more interesting, but we'll do a, a lot of other modern preparations as well.

Tim Fulton Give me some examples of dishes people might get there.

Katie Randazzo My grandmother was notoriously famous for making veal parmesan, and I say veal in quotation marks-

Tim Fulton Okay

Katie Randazzo ... because it was actually chicken. And she believed that if you pounded it thin enough, then no one would know the difference between the veal and the chicken.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo So it was a tradition every time we would go visit her in Akron, she was like, "Oh, try my veal parmesan." We're like, "Okay, Mimi." You know? So one of the first things we discussed when we were discussing the restaurant and the concept and the name and everything behind it was that story.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And so-

Tim Fulton And so did you get there just because you were looking for a name, or you set out and you were like, "I'm gonna do this and I'm gonna name it this"?

Katie Randazzo It was... The name has been in development for, I would say, about two years almost. And there was a couple other spaces that we had looked at that fell through.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo But I was f- I was very dead set on naming it Ambrose and Eve.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Katie Randazzo I think it has a nice flow to it. It's masculine, it's feminine.

Tim Fulton Yeah. Ambrose is not a name that I'm actually familiar with.

Katie Randazzo Right.

Matthew Hagens It's a really old school name.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton What's sort of the short... You're Matthew and hence Matt. Is there a short version of Ambrose?

Katie Randazzo Bro.

Tim Fulton Well, and it should be said, your background, Katie, you are the proprietor of originally Hala Food Truck and also Hala, which is in-

Katie Randazzo Woodlands

Tim Fulton ... Woodlands Tavern.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton How did you get into this business?

Katie Randazzo Well, I used to date this girl. I met her six years ago, I think.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo She lived in New York at the time, and I was feeling very stagnant in Columbus, and I liked her, so I decided to move to New York and push my boundaries and learn more about the culinary field and get more educated at that as well. And she's Jewish, and I was in the process of opening a food truck, but I put it on hold to move to New York.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And she moved back with me to open the truck.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo And because she had not ever worked in the service industry, we, we or I, had decided on doing Jewish food because I wanted a way for her to feel connected to the business-

Tim Fulton Okay

Katie Randazzo ... and be able to fit in and bring some ideas to the table.

Tim Fulton But you're Jewish as well.

Katie Randazzo No, I'm not. I'm Sicilian.

Tim Fulton I didn't know that.

Katie Randazzo Yeah, I'm not Jewish. My nose confuses people- ... but no, I'm J- I'm not Jewish.

Tim Fulton Well, I guess I always assumed because you were the proprietor of-

Katie Randazzo Right

Tim Fulton ... you know, a, a Jewish food establishment.

Katie Randazzo Well, I opened a Jewish food establishment based on this ex-girlfriend.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens It's important. It's important.

Tim Fulton Well, sometimes that's the way it goes.

Matthew Hagens The ish part is really important there.

Katie Randazzo Yeah, Jew-ish.

Tim Fulton You know, it's Jewie, or, you know.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton And so Hala's going well, and sort of this Ambrose and Eve is sort of the next endeavor for you.

Katie Randazzo Correct, yeah.

Tim Fulton Great. And Matthew, I don't believe you and I have ever met.

Matthew Hagens I don't think so.

Tim Fulton Where... Tell me about your background. How did you get here?

Matthew Hagens I don't know. 39 years ago, my parents met.

Tim Fulton Two people loved each other very much.

Matthew Hagens That's too, that's too far back.

Katie Randazzo Well, that's questionable.

Matthew Hagens I used to work in, like, I don't know, an office. I used to work for AT&T for a really long time.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens I worked there for eight years, and I think I liked it for eight days.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens Eventually, they offered me, uh, an early retirement, and I took it, and I had been cooking off and on and then before that.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens And it's something that I like doing. I like taking care of people.

Tim Fulton Uh-huh.

Matthew Hagens So-

Tim Fulton Dinner parties in your home, or you were-

Matthew Hagens Well, I mean, I worked-

Tim Fulton ... cooking on the... like working in a kitchen on the side?

Matthew Hagens Like working, yeah, working in a kitchen on, on the side. I got laid off from AT&T, and I worked at this little place called Elemental that was over where Black Creek Bistro is now.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Yeah, like actual employment from time to time-

Tim Fulton Okay

Matthew Hagens ... but mostly it was kind of like fun stuff. So I cashed out my retirement and went to DC and-

Tim Fulton Okay

Matthew Hagens ... got a job at a fine dining restaurant and got my... got the shit kicked out of me for, like, a full year.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens Um, and then kind of like half got it kicked out of me for a couple more years. And then I bought a food truck and drove it back-

Tim Fulton Okay

Matthew Hagens ... and ran a food truck here for a couple of years.

Tim Fulton What food truck is that?

Matthew Hagens It was the Swoop food truck. It was-

Tim Fulton Ah, okay

Matthew Hagens ... really big in this neighborhood.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Matthew Hagens It was huge. We did some, some additional pop-ups, and were kind of like growing on track to get a restaurant open, and then some things happened.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens And then I didn't do it anymore. So-

Tim Fulton Well, and that's the way that kind of stuff goes. I mean, as someone who was passively involved in a, you know, food establishment, that's sort of how things happen.

Matthew Hagens Yeah. It's life. That's what happens.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Matthew Hagens So then I was at the Flatiron for a while.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens Then I was at the Rossi until pretty recently.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens And now I'm doing this.

Tim Fulton Great. Great. Talk about the process of you guys had looked at a couple of different spaces that had fallen through. I imagine sometimes the price wasn't right, or somebody else came in and... Or the landlord wasn't amenable to what you w- guys wanted to do there. So what I-

Katie Randazzo Or sometimes-

Tim Fulton Sometimes what I like to do is sort of get into the inside baseball of how did you do this? For someone who hasn't opened a restaurant or is thinking of just opening a business, what are the pitfalls of it?

Katie Randazzo Don't do it.

Tim Fulton It is way too much work.

Katie Randazzo It's like, don't do it. I've always wanted to put a restaurant into an old house because I feel like customer service is very big for me, as well as for Matt.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo It's something that we're actually really gonna focus on in the restaurant.

Tim Fulton Okay. So similar to, like, Elena's. Is that what you mean by old house?

Katie Randazzo Well, yeah.

Tim Fulton Oh, okay.

Katie Randazzo Yeah, yeah. I thought you were talking about customer service. We've talked more at this point about service by far than we've talked about food.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo So the idea of putting something into a house where you immediately walk in, you immediately feel comfortable, you immediately feel like you're in someone's home and that you're gonna have a great time and someone's gonna take care of you in that mom or grandmother kind of way always has appealed to me.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo So there was a house over on Washington over kind of by Parsons Children's-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Katie Randazzo ... Hospital area.

Tim Fulton So on the other side of the freeway.

Katie Randazzo Correct.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo That I had looked at. But in order to build that out, it was an old house, and so to build it out into a restaurant, it was just gonna be way too much money.

Tim Fulton Was it even zoned for that?

Katie Randazzo It was zoned for that-

Tim Fulton Okay

Katie Randazzo ... actually, yeah. And there were some structural issues, and so passed on that. And then Till was for sale-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Katie Randazzo ... last year. Was it last year?

Tim Fulton Yeah, it was last year.

Katie Randazzo Last year. And w- we got into some pretty heavy negotiations on Till.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo But Blake Compton came in and did a walkthrough and was like, "Don't do it."

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And there were some-

Tim Fulton Just you knew it was gonna be too much.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo He was like, "There's a lot of structural issues. There's some issues with the hood system." And also the lease was really shoddy, and it just felt really-

Tim Fulton Well, they wanted to continue to own the space, right?

Katie Randazzo No. The original ch- chef's parents owned that building.

Tim Fulton Ah, okay.

Katie Randazzo And he's, he was selling the building.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And the lease was, like, super shoddy, and it just came, seemed a little shady. So I passed on that. And so then one day I was at Seven Sun, and Colin Castor came up to me and he was like, "Hey, are you still looking for a restaurant space?" And I said, "Well, as a matter of fact, I am." And he go- he said, "We are opening a sour beer bar on South High."

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo "And the space next to us is available for a lease for a restaurant. I really think that you should take a look at it." And he emailed the Kelly brothers, AKA The Property Brothers. They were s- both so handsome.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo They look so much alike. They're like twins that aren't twins.

Tim Fulton Oh.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Like that show.

Katie Randazzo Like The Property Brothers.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton I don't watch that show. I didn't-

Katie Randazzo I don't watch it either. I just-

Tim Fulton I've seen it.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Yes.

Katie Randazzo And so he put me in touch with those guys, and the ball just started rolling.

Tim Fulton Okay. And the price was right and the-

Katie Randazzo The price was right. The lease was, the lease agreement was great. They were really flexible on any changes that we wanted to put in.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And since the, my food truck has been at Seven Sun for four years-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Katie Randazzo ... two days a week for four years, I already have a really, really good relationship with them. And Matt also has a really good relationship with them.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo It just felt right. It felt very symbiotic.

Tim Fulton Right.

Katie Randazzo Felt like we were gonna have a good partnership without being partners, and that we could really feed off of each other and generate a really good buzz on that corner.

Tim Fulton That's great.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton And walk me through where exactly is it?

Katie Randazzo Trying to think what the cross street is, and I can't. Franklin.

Tim Fulton It's across the street from Grange Insurance and The Local bar and-

Katie Randazzo So you're south of the Panera?

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Yes.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo About a block south of the Panera.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo Next to...

Tim Fulton Colacci

Katie Randazzo ... Colacci Republic.

Tim Fulton Colacci Republic. And there's a Head Shop that went in over there too.

Katie Randazzo So it's that little strip of-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Katie Randazzo ... bui- it's not the anti- big antiquers.

Tim Fulton It is the old antique mall.

Katie Randazzo Oh, okay.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Great. Where we're gonna be half of that.

Tim Fulton And so that's being, that's being sub-sectioned.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton And so, got it. Now I understand.

Katie Randazzo We'll be on one half, and Seven Sun will be on the other half.

Tim Fulton Now I understand. Cool. Talk to me more about some of the dishes that you guys expect to be serving.

Katie Randazzo Back to the chicken Parmesan.

Tim Fulton Uh-huh.

Katie Randazzo The veal Parmesan.

Tim Fulton Yeah. So we kinda knew initially that we wanted to figure out some way to do that, if it was gonna be chicken or if it was gonna actually be veal.

Katie Randazzo Mm-hmm.

Tim Fulton And we were like, "Well, veal sweetbreads taste exactly like chicken, only the best chicken you've ever had." Right? So we did some playing around, some tinkering with that. We felt like it needed a little bit more acidity to kinda, like, cut through the richness of that. So-

Katie Randazzo Yeah

Tim Fulton ... started to play around with a raspberry marin- marinara, and then we have, like, a really good thing that we're super happy about.

Katie Randazzo It's, it's beautiful. It's a really, really good dish.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo We have to get the right cheese or my dad will kill us.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo So a lot of the things at the restaurant will be, I'm not gonna say, like, small plates, but tidier portions.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo You know, k- kind of actually meant for everyone.

Tim Fulton So it's not comfort food. That should not... You don't imagine people would say that to describe it. It's much more Americana.

Katie Randazzo I would, I would say, like, much more Americana.

Tim Fulton I think we're gonna be compared to Rockmill, Sycamore.

Katie Randazzo Yeah. But, you know, the food will kinda, like, stand on its own and be its own thing. We're talking about cheese balls, and one of the things we know for sure that we are gonna serve is a comfort food deal, but-

Tim Fulton Uh-huh

Katie Randazzo ... you'll order, uh, fried chicken, and then someone will bring you a bucket of fried chicken, and then someone will bring you a tray of macaroni and cheese, and then someone will bring you-

Tim Fulton Okay

Katie Randazzo ... like, some coleslaw, and then someone will bring you braised green beans, and we're gonna just, like, lay it all the way out.

Tim Fulton Awesome.

Katie Randazzo So we have some ideas kinda tailored around how some of those dishes made us feel.

Tim Fulton Got it. And have you guys done pop-ups yet?

Katie Randazzo We've done two.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo I think we've done-

Tim Fulton Three

Katie Randazzo ... three. Yeah, like two, two or three.

Tim Fulton And so you're sorta using that to figure out the menu, um, see what people like, see, get hopefully honest criticism behind it. Not a huge revenue generator, I imagine.

Katie Randazzo No.

Tim Fulton No, not huge.

Katie Randazzo More keeping people engaged, I think.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo Yeah. Because, you know, like you say, we're gonna open a restaurant in, you know, at that time in over a year.

Tim Fulton Right.

Katie Randazzo We just felt like it was best for us to do that as a way to test some things out and try to do some things.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo But also to keep people engaged, like-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Katie Randazzo ... "No, this is actually, this is still happening. This is what we're doing." Because that happens a lot

Matthew Hagens People will be like, "Oh, I heard there was gonna be a Stauf's opening here."

Tim Fulton Right-

Matthew Hagens And I-

Tim Fulton 'Cause I'm sure that was a plan at some point

Matthew Hagens I showed up today to get some coffee, and it's not open yet.

Tim Fulton No, uh, the Stauf's here at the Idea Foundry opens on the 21st.

Matthew Hagens And it made me really sad, but I didn't... Like, from hearing that there was gonna be a Stauf's open-

Tim Fulton Right

Matthew Hagens ... to there being a Stauf's open, there's, there's nothing in between.

Tim Fulton Right.

Matthew Hagens So we're just trying to, like, maintain something in between.

Tim Fulton Good.

Katie Randazzo Nice.

Tim Fulton Smart. So what's your timeline look like right now?

Katie Randazzo March.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton So you've got some time.

Katie Randazzo Which actually is coming up pretty quickly.

Tim Fulton It is.

Matthew Hagens Well, yeah, it feels like a long time to some people, but to me, it feels like it's a wolf, like, right on my heels.

Katie Randazzo Like, in my head, I'm already in December. I'm like, okay, I'm, like, in December, and then January comes and we get the keys, and then it's go, go, go.

Tim Fulton Right. And so what's sort of the build-out plan look like? Like, what do you have to... What has to be arranged in order for you guys to get going?

Matthew Hagens So they actually just finished, like, the baseline demo-

Katie Randazzo Right

Matthew Hagens ... here, uh, a few days ago.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens And they're doing, like, a walkthrough to check our MEP and all our specs, and make sure that everything's gonna work the way, you know, at least in planning.

Tim Fulton What's MEP?

Matthew Hagens I don't know. It's mechanical something.

Tim Fulton Mechanical, electrical-

Matthew Hagens Extra special

Tim Fulton ... power.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Something.

Katie Randazzo Something like that. I don't-

Tim Fulton Okay

Katie Randazzo ... I don't know the technical term for it. I just know MEP.

Matthew Hagens I... Yeah, like I, I, I know what they do, I just don't know-

Tim Fulton Got it

Matthew Hagens ... what it stands for.

Tim Fulton Okay. Cool. I'll put it in the show notes.

Matthew Hagens And so what we'll get, hopefully, on the other side of that is an okay to go ahead and white box the space.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens You know, drywall. Like-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Matthew Hagens ... no, no, no finishing touches. There's gonna be an elevation in the kitchen.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens There's gonna be, like, a really huge chunk of the kitchen that is, uh-

Katie Randazzo They're tearing down

Matthew Hagens ... designated for, uh, for-

Katie Randazzo Oh, for the-

Matthew Hagens ... ADA ramp. But they're-

Katie Randazzo Then they're tearing down half the building.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens So there's some large things that need to do, uh, need to be done, and then they'll be kinda, like, reassembling it into this nice, tidy package.

Tim Fulton Gotcha. So while you guys say you're taking over... 'Cause it's a huge... When you said half of it, I was like, that's huge.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton But-

Katie Randazzo It's gonna be a little bit smaller than probably what you re-

Tim Fulton Not much.

Katie Randazzo Not much. It's gonna... It's a, it's a decent-sized space, for sure.

Tim Fulton How many seats are you looking at?

Katie Randazzo Between 80 and 100.

Tim Fulton That's a lot.

Katie Randazzo With a patio.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo We're gonna have a patio.

Tim Fulton That's a lot.

Katie Randazzo And that patio's beautiful.

Tim Fulton Awesome.

Katie Randazzo Ugh.

Matthew Hagens Yeah, the renderings are-

Katie Randazzo Oh

Matthew Hagens ... are very exciting.

Katie Randazzo So good-looking.

Tim Fulton So you guys are working on... You have a permanent pop-up at Three Sheets. Tell me about that.

Matthew Hagens Ambrose & Eve's Burger Shack.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens It's pretty straight up and down, just that.

Tim Fulton You serve burgers.

Matthew Hagens We serve burgers-

Katie Randazzo Burgers and, like-

Matthew Hagens ... chicken sandwiches

Katie Randazzo ... classic riffs on, really, our favorite junk food to eat, like jalapeno poppers and Funyuns and potato skins.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens It kinda jumped out at one of our pop-ups. We had a junk food pop-up.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens We were, like, kind of already talking about doing this pop-up at Three Sheets, and we were like, "Well, we should just keep this food, 'cause it's really good."

Tim Fulton So is it technically a pop-up anymore if you're semi-permanent?

Katie Randazzo I would say that-

Matthew Hagens I think it's a pop, I think it's a pop-up if you don't own it.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Okay. There you go.

Matthew Hagens Yeah. Um-

Tim Fulton 'Cause you don't... So wait, would technically Hala at-

Katie Randazzo Woodlands

Tim Fulton ... Woodlands be considered a pop-up?

Katie Randazzo I think so, yeah.

Tim Fulton Okay. There you go. All right. Where's Three Sheets?

Katie Randazzo It's, uh, next to the Hy-Vee on South High, very close to where our restaurant's gonna be.

Matthew Hagens 560 South High Street.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And w- part of the reason why we wanted to be in that neighborhood is so we could generate buzz and-

Tim Fulton Get to know people

Katie Randazzo ... get the neighborhood f- familiar with our style and, like-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Katie Randazzo ... things that they can expect at Ambrose & Eve the restaurant, even though the style's gonna be completely different-

Tim Fulton Right

Katie Randazzo ... food. But still, like-

Matthew Hagens But the attention that's paid to it is the same.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Matthew Hagens You know? It's like-

Tim Fulton Well, and it's interesting. I think you guys are slowly but surely br- building a brand up.

Katie Randazzo Oh, for sure.

Matthew Hagens Yeah, because, I mean, that's, I shouldn't say end goal, but that's the goal. Like, that's the way through.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Matthew Hagens We wanna open a few restaurants, and we don't wanna, like, open this restaurant and then open another of the same restaurant, and then another of the same restaurant. We'd like to own a variety of restaurants, uh, that do different things and are all interesting, but have kind of a s- similar underlying aesthetic.

Tim Fulton You guys are the future Cameron Mitchells.

Katie Randazzo I wouldn't compare us to him, but yes.

Tim Fulton Fair. Fair. Have you reached out to the... Is it Klatsche?

Katie Randazzo Klatsche Republic.

Tim Fulton Klatsche Republic guys.

Katie Randazzo I actually went to high school with that guy. My mom and his mom-

Tim Fulton With which one?

Katie Randazzo Klatshu.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo My mom and his mom taught high school together, or junior high together.

Tim Fulton No kidding.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton So I lived right next door in high school to Dustin.

Katie Randazzo Did you?

Tim Fulton Not high school, college.

Katie Randazzo Oh, okay.

Tim Fulton When I was at Ohio State-

Katie Randazzo Oh, really?

Tim Fulton ... we, we both lived, like, off of King Avenue.

Katie Randazzo Oh, that's so funny.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Matthew Hagens I've been in twice-

Tim Fulton Uh-huh

Matthew Hagens ... since we've been kicking around in that neighborhood, and I enjoyed my food a lot. But I feel like they have a lot of regulars. Like, like-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Matthew Hagens ... the people that came in around me, like, while I was there, everybody was, like, greeted on a first-name basis.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens They, they, they walked in the door and they knew what they were gonna eat.

Tim Fulton So there's a testament to that. Yeah.

Katie Randazzo That's huge. And customer service is such a big deal that I feel like a lot of restaurants and businesses fail on on a regular basis.

Tim Fulton Yeah. Well, and what's interesting, what I've seen sort of is as we had that big sort of, I don't wanna call it a renaissance, but, like, everything got really good really fast. Places like Curio and Sycamore and, like, all came up. And then some places, I am not gonna name which ones, you go back, you know, maybe even... It took a couple years, but a couple years later it's like, oh, there's not as much, like, they don't wanna tell you about what's in it because maybe they don't know or maybe they're too busy, and there's not as much focus on the customer service end of things.

Matthew Hagens I think that's fully fair to say.

Katie Randazzo I completely agree.

Tim Fulton Well, okay.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Have you seen that?

Katie Randazzo Oh, absolutely.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo And that's, like, why Matt and I have had so many conversations on customer service, continued education with the servers.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Like, wine education, spirit education, food education, so that they can answer the questions, they can tell you where it came from. They know what's in it. Like-

Tim Fulton Well, and they're exci- and they need to be excited

Katie Randazzo ... and they're excited about it. Like, they-

Tim Fulton 'Cause the problem is-

Matthew Hagens Yeah

Tim Fulton ... is those people who are super good at customer service and, like, take extra time and, like, train themselves and read books, and I'm thinking about more, like, alcohol and beer at this point- Who, like, wanna talk to the customer about, like, what is a sour beer or what makes a lager. And those people actually, because they're so good, they get promoted to management.

Katie Randazzo Mm-hmm.

Tim Fulton And then the people that come in under them don't take the time or as passionate, and they're just sort of like, "This is my job to sling beers or drinks or whatever it is." And yeah, I mean, that really does differentiate a business to me.

Katie Randazzo Well, I, I think, um, I think part of that is people are going to college, and they're like, "I'm just serving and this is just like my part-time job-"

Tim Fulton Right

Katie Randazzo ... while I work on my degree." But people are maybe not ashamed isn't the right word, but, like, it's okay to be a professional server.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo That, that can be your career, and it's a-

Matthew Hagens Like a restaurant professional?

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Like, that is a real thing.

Tim Fulton Absolutely it is.

Matthew Hagens And when you go other places, you see that. Like-

Tim Fulton Right

Matthew Hagens ... even here in DC.

Katie Randazzo Like New York, LA, like-

Matthew Hagens Yeah

Katie Randazzo ... that's, that's totally a thing there.

Tim Fulton Well-

Matthew Hagens But there are pe- I'm, so, like, I'm thinking, first of all, uh, while we may be snarky about it sometimes, the Cameron Mitchell restaurants do a really good job of at least having a baseline-

Katie Randazzo I completely agree with that

Matthew Hagens ... of great customer service.

Tim Fulton They attract people. They take care of people.

Matthew Hagens Yeah.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo They take care-

Tim Fulton Well-

Katie Randazzo ... of their staff extremely well. Like, I will say that I admire his business motto and the way that he takes care of customers-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Katie Randazzo ... and the way he takes care of guests. It's great.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Like, absolutely it's great.

Tim Fulton That milkshake thing and whatever.

Katie Randazzo What?

Tim Fulton Do you know about the milkshake thing?

Katie Randazzo No.

Tim Fulton So if you ever go into a Cameron Mitchell restaurant, some of the servers or host staff or managers have a l- a little lapel pin that is a milkshake, and it's representative of going into a place and saying, "Hey, all I want is a milkshake," and there's no milkshake on the menu. And the, and the standard should be if you have the things you need to make a milkshake, just make them a milkshake rather than, you know, having to dec- what's the... There's a movie where the guy wants to order a BLT, and there's all the ingredients for the BLT are on-

Katie Randazzo Oh, yeah. What is that movie?

Tim Fulton Is it Jack Nicholson is in that scene?

Katie Randazzo I don't... I, I know what you're talking about, but I don't recall the-

Tim Fulton I will put that in the show notes as well. But it's basically just the philosophy, give them what they want. And now that I think about it, it's sort of the established places like Barcelona, the places that have been in Columbus for, like, 20 years or 30 years, I don't know how long they've been here, and Tapatio was when it was still around, was those are career servers, and so they're passionate about what they-

Katie Randazzo Lindy's has a lot of career servers.

Tim Fulton Lindy's, great example as well. Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton So-

Katie Randazzo We're hoping to attract those people.

Matthew Hagens Literally.

Katie Randazzo Literally.

Matthew Hagens Yeah.

Katie Randazzo 'Cause we'll also come up-

Tim Fulton Come and work for Ambrose and Eve.

Katie Randazzo So we're gonna offer profit sharing for our-

Tim Fulton So that's part of your model?

Katie Randazzo Correct.

Tim Fulton Yeah, okay.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton So yeah, I mean-

Matthew Hagens Have you worked out how that's gonna look exactly?

Katie Randazzo Eh, we've talked about it, but we don't have anything I would say in, like, finite details as of-

Tim Fulton Okay

Katie Randazzo ... yet, but it's-

Tim Fulton So basically what you guys will do is say employees have X percentage of ownership of the company.

Katie Randazzo Mm-hmm.

Tim Fulton It's not necessarily that they're not gonna get vested or anything.

Katie Randazzo Right.

Tim Fulton But, but while they work there, what, every quarter, every-

Matthew Hagens We'll pay down a percentage of the restaurant's profits.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens Kind of a scale across employees to management.

Tim Fulton And that'll be based on hours worked, I assume, plus seniority.

Matthew Hagens Hours worked, seniority.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens We just feel like it will really incentivize people to do a good job-

Tim Fulton Yeah

Matthew Hagens ... to be professional.

Katie Randazzo To take care in it 'cause th- the- essentially, like, that restaurant is also theirs in a way-

Tim Fulton Right

Katie Randazzo ... so they'll treat it like it's their own, it's, it's their own space, so.

Tim Fulton Do you feel like you're gonna have to open up your books a little bit and sort of say, like, "Here's what... Here's how we're doing-"

Katie Randazzo I-

Tim Fulton ... basically

Matthew Hagens I think that's what that is going to be.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm. I'm just super curious 'cause I, as a somebody who's done, who's been involved in a restaurant space sort of passively and then also as somebody who's consulted on, like, bar marketing and stuff, I always get sort of an itch when somebody's like, "I'm gonna spend this amount of money on this," and I haven't been asked about it, and I'm like, "That seems like a lot of money to spend on Wi-Fi," or, "Seems like a lot of money to spend on ca- like, commercial cable for a restaurant or a bar is crazy expensive."

Matthew Hagens It's really expensive.

Katie Randazzo It's really expensive. We don't want we don't want TVs.

Tim Fulton Well, yeah, but it's, it's stuff like that, and I just wonder if, and this is totally just me thinking things through, is do you have a risk of the employees then being like, "Why are we spending so much money on veal?" Do you worry you're gonna open yourself up to that? I guess I'm just wondering-

Katie Randazzo I, I never-

Tim Fulton ... if you've thought about it

Katie Randazzo ... I never worried about it.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens I, I don't really. That's why I kinda, like, stepped back a bit from employee owners-

Tim Fulton Okay

Matthew Hagens ... to profit sharing. Like, those are not the same thing.

Tim Fulton Yes, absolutely.

Matthew Hagens Or, or they don't have to be the same things. They can be.

Tim Fulton Right.

Matthew Hagens So we make-

Tim Fulton It's basically bonuses.

Matthew Hagens Yeah.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton I mean-

Matthew Hagens Performance-based bonuses.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Absolutely.

Tim Fulton Exactly, and I mean, you guys aren't gonna put yourselves out, but yeah, it's based on the success of the space.

Matthew Hagens And it's tied directly to all of our performance.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Matthew Hagens From how we implement our ideas into the kitchen to how people execute them-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Matthew Hagens ... to how our GM runs the flow of service to how, you know, individual servers and bartenders, like, execute it.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm.

Katie Randazzo How we manage our labor, how we manage our food costs.

Tim Fulton Right. How are you guys splitting, as business partners, how are you sort of splitting up your duties?

Matthew Hagens Well, so-

Tim Fulton What's your role?

Matthew Hagens Generally, generally, because I am a little bit more of a night owl and she likes to get moving a little bit more during the day-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Matthew Hagens ... she'll be more or less in charge of what's going on during the day, and I'll be more or less in charge of what's going on at night.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens You know, we'll meet, like, all of the food that we put out will be, will be our food, and we'll test all the recipes together.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens We'll train people to implement them together.

Katie Randazzo Exactly the same way. There won't be any differences.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Katie Randazzo Which is important.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo I think that's very important.

Tim Fulton Consistency, yeah.

Katie Randazzo Consistency, and we, we are on the same page with that in the Burger Shack right now. Like, before I send anything out, I ask Matt if he's okay with it, and he does the same with me as well-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Katie Randazzo ... because I think there's a mutual level of respect that we have for each other-

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm

Katie Randazzo ... each other's opinions, and also, like, we wanna be successful, so we wanna run... It's better to have two eyes-

Tim Fulton Right

Katie Randazzo ... four eyes-

Tim Fulton They both have glasses

Katie Randazzo Eight eyes.

Tim Fulton Uh-huh.

Katie Randazzo Eight eyes in the kitchen than, than none, so, like, yeah.

Tim Fulton Right. So what about, like, I'm just curious about, like, what about accounting? What about payroll? What about-

Matthew Hagens I think it's a really good idea to-

Tim Fulton Hire someone

Matthew Hagens ... do the things that you are good at.

Katie Randazzo Yep.

Tim Fulton Yep.

Matthew Hagens And hire people to do the things that you are not great at.

Tim Fulton Again, having done this before, I'm just curious, what have you identified at this point of, like, mm, we probably need a lawyer sometimes, or-

Matthew Hagens Well-

Tim Fulton ... like, we need an accountant

Matthew Hagens ... so a lawyer, a bookkeeper, an accountant.

Tim Fulton Mm-hmm. Are those separate?

Matthew Hagens Yes.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens Bookkeepers-

Tim Fulton Day-to-day

Matthew Hagens ... that's actually the difference. Like, day-to-day-

Tim Fulton Uh-huh

Matthew Hagens ... bookkeepers are much less expensive.

Tim Fulton Yep.

Matthew Hagens And what they do is they kinda, like, collate things. They-

Tim Fulton They keep everything

Matthew Hagens ... they file receipts. They put things into, into spreadsheets.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Matthew Hagens And then your accountant does the heavy lifting.

Tim Fulton The taxes.

Katie Randazzo That type of thing.

Tim Fulton Right.

Matthew Hagens Yeah.

Katie Randazzo And the bookkeeper could easily be the general manager, too.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Katie Randazzo I mean-

Tim Fulton Absolutely. It's just somebody who has that skill set and knows how to work QuickBooks or whatever you guys decide on using.

Matthew Hagens Yeah.

Tim Fulton So.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Cool. You're gonna have beer and liquor, or-

Katie Randazzo Yes.

Matthew Hagens Yes.

Tim Fulton Awesome. Congratulations.

Matthew Hagens We're gonna focus on ciders.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens We feel like people's idea of cider is very American right now.

Katie Randazzo Yeah. It's like, what?

Tim Fulton It's the-

Katie Randazzo Angry Orchard? Like, ooh, Angry Orchard.

Tim Fulton Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Yeah.

Tim Fulton There are, like, eight Angry Orchards, though.

Katie Randazzo Right.

Tim Fulton So-

Matthew Hagens But you will have a sort of a depth and breadth of a, of a cider menu.

Tim Fulton Yeah. Liquor?

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Yes.

Katie Randazzo We'll have liquor.

Tim Fulton Okay, great. So you'll have some cocktails. You'll have-

Matthew Hagens And then we'll have a couple of draft, and then we'll... W- we're gonna have a couple of drafts. We're gonna have-

Katie Randazzo Literally, like, two.

Matthew Hagens We're gonna... Yeah.

Tim Fulton That's cheaper-

Katie Randazzo Yeah

Tim Fulton ... for implementation. I mean-

Katie Randazzo Well, the space is limited.

Tim Fulton Right.

Katie Randazzo So, I mean-

Matthew Hagens Well, like, it's a pretty big space, but there are two walls in the middle of that-

Tim Fulton Okay

Matthew Hagens ... restaurant that cannot move because they're holding the building up.

Tim Fulton They're load-bearing, right. Okay.

Katie Randazzo Everyone's a-

Matthew Hagens So, and then the, we have a lead-lined room. Uh-

Tim Fulton Oh, it was a bank.

Matthew Hagens Oh.

Tim Fulton Or something.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Matthew Hagens Or something.

Katie Randazzo So that can't come down either, so.

Matthew Hagens So, you know, like, it, it would be cost-prohibitive to do anything with that.

Tim Fulton Right.

Matthew Hagens So those things kinda, like, pinch our space, and then some of the space in the room where we're gonna put the bar is being co-opted for a flight of stairs to go upstairs to the apartment that's upstairs.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Matthew Hagens So there are so many, like, really, really good local craft beers that are available in bottles and cans-

Tim Fulton Yeah. Thankfully

Matthew Hagens ... uh, right now that we feel like we can still manage a really good selection, but-

Tim Fulton You gonna keep PBR tall boys there for me, or-

Matthew Hagens I mean, I almost feel like you have-

Katie Randazzo Only if you stock them.

Matthew Hagens Well, maybe...

Katie Randazzo We'll keep them in the kitchen.

Tim Fulton Okay.

Katie Randazzo It'll be a kitchen beer you can buy for the kitchen.

Tim Fulton Got it.

Matthew Hagens And the, and there'll be an excellent for you.

Katie Randazzo Yeah.

Tim Fulton Thank you.

Katie Randazzo Any-

Matthew Hagens I appreciate that

Katie Randazzo ... anytime, anytime.

Tim Fulton Guys, thank you so much for coming in again.

Matthew Hagens Thanks for having us.

Tim Fulton Is there a website that I can link to?

Matthew Hagens We're working on it.

Tim Fulton Matthew Hagans, Katie Randazzo, Ambrose and Eve, thank you guys so much for coming in.

Matthew Hagens Thank you.

Katie Randazzo Thank you.

Tim Fulton Thank you for listening to the Confluence Cast presented by Columbus Underground. Again, you can get more information on what we discussed today in the show notes for this episode at theconfluencecast.com. Please rate, subscribe, share this episode of the Confluence Cast with your friends, family, contacts, enemies, your favorite restaurateur. If you're interested in sponsoring the Confluence Cast, get in touch with us. We can be reached by email at info@theconfluencecast.com. Our theme music was composed by Benji Robinson. I'm your host, Tim Fulton. Have a great week.